Overview
When a person is found guilty of an offence in Victoria, the court faces a secondary decision: whether or not to record a criminal conviction. A magistrate or judge has the legal discretion to impose a penalty
without recording a conviction under
s 8 of the Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic). Avoiding a recorded conviction can be the single most consequential factor in protecting a person's future employment, professional licensing, and international travel rights.
The Statutory Test: Section 8
A court does not grant a non-conviction order out of leniency — it must strictly apply the statutory criteria. When a non-conviction order is sought, the court must balance three specific considerations:
- The nature of the offence — the gravity, objective seriousness, and specific circumstances of the conduct. Minor or isolated lapses in judgment are far more likely to yield a non-conviction than planned, violent, or highly destructive offences.
- The character and past history of the offender — a person with an otherwise unblemished record, strong community ties, and a history of good character is a strong candidate. Prior interactions with the justice system substantially reduce the likelihood of this order.
- The impact on well-being and employment — the court must directly evaluate how recording a conviction will impact the offender's economic or social well-being. This centres on current employment status, future career prospects, trade licences, or professional requirements.
The Interaction With the Spent Convictions Act 2021 (Vic)
A non-conviction order and a spent conviction are different things. Under the
Spent Convictions Act 2021 (Vic):
| Outcome |
Criminal Record Entry |
Visibility on Police Check |
| Not guilty verdict |
None |
Zero impact on employment, travel, or licensing |
| Guilty — without conviction order |
Finding of guilt recorded but no conviction — spent immediately |
Does not appear on standard Nationally Coordinated Criminal History Checks (unless an exemption sector applies) |
| Guilty — recorded conviction |
Conviction recorded — visible for minimum 10 years (adult) |
Highly disruptive. Triggers automatic bars in specific industries, licensing rejections, and international travel visa restrictions |
Serious convictions — including violent or sexual offences, or sentences exceeding 30 months imprisonment — are never automatically spent and require an explicit application to the Magistrates' Court once the waiting period expires.
Critical exception: Even where a conviction or finding of guilt without conviction is spent, certain sensitive employment sectors are legally exempt and may still view historical findings of guilt — including working with children, aged care, healthcare, public transport, law enforcement, and legal professions.
Persuading the Court: What Works
Written Submissions and Character References
Written testimonials from employers, community leaders, or family members must be carefully structured. They should explicitly state that the referee is aware of the specific charges before the court, yet can vouch for the offender's everyday integrity, work ethic, and genuine remorse. A reference that does not acknowledge the charge carries less weight.
Concrete Evidence of Professional Impact
Vague assertions that a conviction "might hurt career prospects" carry little weight. The defence should provide official regulatory guidelines, employment contracts, or letters from industry bodies proving that a recorded conviction will result in termination, loss of a practising certificate, or a complete bar from a chosen trade. Specificity is decisive.
Non-Conviction vs. Diversion
A non-conviction order under s 8 follows a finding of guilt — the finding is made but the conviction is not recorded. Diversion under s 59 of the
Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic) results in no finding of guilt at all. Where diversion is available and appropriate, it provides a stronger protection than a non-conviction order, because it leaves no finding of guilt on the record.