Sections 52A to 52K of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) create specific offences where a service provider (a person who provides treatment or support services to a person with a cognitive impairment) engages in sexual conduct with that person. These offences apply regardless of whether consent was given. The maximum penalty for sexual penetration is Level 5 (10 years)' imprisonment.
Charged under ss.52A–52K Crimes Act 1958? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation. Whether the conduct falls within the section, including what counts as “treatment or support services” and whether the relationship existed at the time, are critical questions.
Sections 52A to 52K of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) form a specialised code of offences dealing with sexual conduct by service providers towards people with a cognitive impairment who receive their treatment or support services. The scheme recognises that people with cognitive impairments who receive care or support services are particularly vulnerable to exploitation by those in positions of trust.
The offences are distinct from general sexual assault offences. They do not require proof that the complainant did not consent. The service provider relationship is itself the basis for the criminal prohibition.
Section 52A of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) defines “cognitive impairment” to include intellectual disability, dementia, neurological disorder, and brain injury. The definition does not require a formal diagnosis. Whether a person had a cognitive impairment within the meaning of the Act at the relevant time is a question of fact. Medical and expert evidence is typically required to establish it.
Section 52A defines "treatment or support services" to include services provided to a person with a cognitive impairment in connection with their disability or impairment. A "service provider" is an organisation or person that provides such services. The offences apply to a person who is either a service provider themselves, or who works for a service provider and provides treatment or support services to the complainant. The relationship at the time of the conduct is what matters.
The main offences under this group of provisions are:
| Section | Offence | Maximum penalty |
|---|---|---|
| s.52B | Sexual penetration of a person with cognitive impairment by a service provider | Level 5 (10 years) |
| s.52C | Sexual touching of a person with cognitive impairment by a service provider | Level 6 (5 years) |
| s.52D | Sexual activity in the presence of a person with cognitive impairment by a service provider | Level 6 (5 years) |
| s.52E | Causing a person with cognitive impairment to be present during sexual activity by a service provider | Level 6 (5 years) |
These offences operate on the basis that the relationship between a provider and a client with cognitive impairment creates an inherent power imbalance that cannot be remedied by apparent consent. Parliament determined that people with cognitive impairments receiving care services are structurally vulnerable to exploitation by those who provide that care, and that apparent consent in that context cannot be treated as genuine consent.
This approach is consistent with similar legislative schemes in Victoria that prohibit sexual conduct in other relationships of trust or dependency, including offences relating to sexual conduct by medical practitioners with patients, and by teachers with students.
The prosecution must establish, beyond reasonable doubt:
The prosecution does not need to prove absence of consent. This simplifies the prosecution's task but does not remove all difficulties of proof. In particular, proof of the relationship and cognitive impairment are live issues in many matters.
The offences require that the accused was a service provider and the complainant was a client of that same program. Where the relationship did not exist at the time of the conduct, for example where the accused was not employed by the program, or where the complainant’s involvement with the program had ended, the foundational element of the offence is not established.
Sections 52H, 52I and 52J of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) provide specific defences. Section 52H applies where the accused reasonably believed they were married to, or the domestic partner of, the complainant. Section 52I applies where the accused reasonably believed the complainant did not have a cognitive impairment or mental illness. Section 52J applies where the accused reasonably believed the service provider did not provide treatment or support services to the complainant. Each defence requires that the belief was genuinely held and was reasonable in the circumstances.
The complainant must have had a cognitive impairment within the meaning of the Act at the relevant time. Where this is disputed, the prosecution must establish it. Medical and expert evidence on the complainant's cognitive functioning is typically central to this issue.
Section 52G of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) provides a specific exception where the accused and the complainant were married or in a domestic partnership at the time of the conduct. This exception applies to the offences under sections 52B to 52D. Whether a relationship qualifies as a domestic partnership within the meaning of the Act, and whether the exception applies on the specific facts, is a matter for legal advice.
The more serious offences under this scheme, particularly s.52B sexual penetration, carry a Level 5 maximum of 10 years and are ordinarily heard in the County Court of Victoria. Less serious offences may be dealt with in the Magistrates' Court depending on prosecutorial election and seriousness.
These matters are classified as sexual offences for the purposes of the Sex Offenders Registration Act 2004 (Vic). A person convicted of a registrable offence must comply with reporting and registration obligations. The registration period and obligations depend on the nature of the offence and the sentence imposed.
The Serious Sex Offenders (Detention and Supervision) Act 2009 (Vic) may apply after sentence where a court assesses an ongoing risk to the community. Courts treat the abuse of a position of trust as a significant aggravating factor in sentencing.
Complainants with cognitive impairments have access to a range of special measures under the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic). These include pre-recorded evidence, the use of a communication assistant, evidence given in a closed court, and restrictions on cross-examination. Courts take a protective approach to the evidence of vulnerable complainants in these matters.
Accused persons in sexual offence proceedings are subject to restrictions on directly cross-examining the complainant in person.
Sexual offences against persons with cognitive impairment by service providers: Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) ss.52B–52E. Up to 10 years’ imprisonment.
Call now for a free consultation with a Victorian criminal lawyer.