Overview
If you are facing allegations involving group-based violence or property destruction during a public disturbance, the relevant charges in Victoria are most likely to be laid under one or more provisions of the
Crimes Act 1958 Section 206 — Rioters Demolishing Buildings
Section 206 applies where a person is one of a group riotously and tumultuously assembled to the disturbance of the public peace, who unlawfully and with force demolishes, pulls down, destroys, or begins to do so to specified categories of structures — including places of worship, houses, stables, warehouses, offices, shops, mills, barns, granaries, government buildings, and mining and manufacturing machinery and infrastructure. Both limbs require the conduct to occur as part of a riotous and tumultuous assembly disturbing the public peace — isolated or solitary destruction does not fall within s 206.
- s 206(1) — demolishing, pulling down, or destroying: 15 years (level 4)
- s 206(2) — injuring or damaging (without demolition): 5 years (level 6)
Section 197 — Destroying or Damaging Property
- s 197(1) — intentionally and without lawful excuse destroying or damaging property: 10 years
- s 197(2) — intending to endanger the life of another: 15 years
- s 197(6)–(7) — committed by fire must be charged as arson: 15 years
Section 195H — Affray
- s 195H(1)(a) — standard affray: 5 years
- s 195H(1)(b) — wearing a face covering to conceal identity: 7 years
- s 195H(5) — aggregation principle: where two or more people use or threaten unlawful violence, their conduct is considered together regardless of whether they acted simultaneously.
Affray may be committed in private as well as public places, and whether or not a person of reasonable firmness is actually present. A threat made only in words, without more, is not sufficient.
Key Questions
Multiple charges? Yes — these sections target different aspects of conduct and a single incident may give rise to charges under more than one provision. Wearing a mask? For affray under s 195H, wearing a face covering primarily to conceal identity increases the maximum penalty from 5 to 7 years. Must someone be touched? Affray does not require physical contact — using or threatening violence in a way that would cause a person of reasonable firmness to be terrified suffices.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I be charged under more than one section for the same incident?
Yes. These sections target different aspects of conduct — s 206 the demolition of specific property categories during a riotous assembly, s 197 general property destruction, and s 195H violent or threatening conduct. A single incident may give rise to charges under more than one provision.
Does it matter if I was wearing a mask?
For affray under s 195H, yes. Wearing a face covering primarily to conceal identity, or to protect against crowd-controlling substances, increases the maximum penalty from 5 to 7 years imprisonment.
Can I be guilty of affray without touching anyone?
Affray does not require physical contact. It is committed by using or threatening unlawful violence in a way that would cause a person of reasonable firmness to be terrified — though a threat made only in words, without more, is not sufficient.
Which Court Hears These Charges?
All three provisions are
indictable offences. They may be heard summarily in the
Magistrates' Court if the accused consents and the court considers it suitable — capped at 2 years imprisonment per single charge. Where the conduct is serious, involves significant property destruction, multiple charges, or facts justifying a penalty beyond that cap, the matter will be committed to the
County Court where the full statutory maximum is available. Charges under s 206(1), given its 15-year maximum, are particularly likely to proceed in the County Court.