Responsibility for Crimes Committed by Other People Victoria | Complicity Criminal Law
Victorian criminal law · Criminal liability

Responsibility for Crimes Committed by Other People

Victorian criminal law extends liability beyond the person who physically carries out an offence. A person who aids, abets, counsels or procures the commission of an offence is taken to have committed that offence and faces the same maximum penalty as the principal offender. Separate offences of conspiracy and incitement can be charged even where the intended crime is never carried out.

Charges based on secondary participation often turn on disputed questions of knowledge and intent. What you knew, when you knew it, and what you intended are all live issues. Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation.

The Statutory Framework

Section 323 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) provides an interpretive rule that extends the definition of "a person who committed an offence" to include secondary participants. It provides that "a person who committed an offence" may include two or more persons who entered into an agreement, arrangement or understanding to commit the offence. This operates alongside the common law doctrines of aiding and abetting, common purpose, and extended joint criminal enterprise, which continue to apply in Victorian criminal proceedings.

The practical effect is that a person who participates in a crime committed by another, or who forms part of a joint criminal enterprise with others, can be convicted of the same offence as the person who physically performed the act.

Aiding and Abetting

At common law, a person who aids, abets, counsels or procures the commission of an offence is a secondary party to that offence and is liable to be convicted and sentenced as if they were the principal offender. This doctrine operates in Victorian criminal law through the general law as applied in conjunction with s.323 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic).

The four modes of secondary participation have distinct meanings:

  • Aid: providing assistance to the principal offender in the commission of the offence. Presence at the scene with prior knowledge and an intention to assist can constitute aiding.
  • Abet: instigating, encouraging or inciting the commission of the offence. Encouragement does not require words - conduct that signals approval or readiness to assist can suffice.
  • Counsel: advising or encouraging the commission of the offence before the event. Counselling must occur prior to the commission of the offence.
  • Procure: producing the commission of the offence by endeavour. Procuring involves causing the offence to be committed, typically by arranging the circumstances in which it occurs.

Each mode requires a mental element. The secondary participant must have knowledge of the essential matters constituting the offence being committed by the principal and must intend to assist or encourage its commission. Presence at the scene alone, without knowledge and intent, does not make a person a secondary participant.

Common Purpose

Common purpose is a doctrine under which each member of a group who agrees to pursue a common criminal purpose is liable for any offence committed by another member of the group in furtherance of that purpose, provided the offence was within the scope of what was agreed or was a foreseeable incident of carrying out the agreed purpose.

Where two or more persons agree to commit a specific offence and one of them commits it while carrying out the agreed plan, all participants who shared the common purpose are liable. The prosecution must prove that the accused was a party to the agreement, that the offence was committed in furtherance of the agreed purpose, and that the accused knew or foresaw the commission of the type of offence that occurred.

Extended Joint Criminal Enterprise

Extended joint criminal enterprise, confirmed by the High Court of Australia in McAuliffe v The Queen (1995) 183 CLR 108, extends liability to members of a joint criminal enterprise for acts committed by co-offenders that go beyond the scope of the agreement, provided the accused foresaw the possibility that a co-offender might commit the act constituting the further offence.

In McAuliffe, the High Court held that a participant in a joint criminal enterprise is liable for a further offence committed by a co-offender during the enterprise if the participant foresaw the possibility of that offence being committed and continued to participate in the enterprise regardless. The test is subjective foresight: what did the accused actually foresee as a possible incident of carrying out the agreement?

Extended joint criminal enterprise arises most commonly in cases involving group violence where a co-offender goes further than the initial agreement contemplated. Where an accused foresees the possibility that a co-offender might use lethal violence but continues to participate in the enterprise, that accused may be convicted of murder if the co-offender kills.

In Miller v The Queen [2016] HCA 30, the High Court confirmed that the doctrine in McAuliffe remains good law in Australia. The Court declined to overrule McAuliffe and apply the approach adopted in the United Kingdom in R v Jogee [2016] UKSC 8, where the UK Supreme Court abolished extended joint criminal enterprise and required proof of actual intent. In Australia, foresight of the possibility of the further offence, coupled with continued participation, remains sufficient.

In McAuliffe v The Queen (1995) 183 CLR 108, the High Court held that a member of a joint criminal enterprise is liable for a further offence committed by a co-offender during the enterprise if the participant foresaw it as a possible incident of the enterprise and continued regardless.

Conspiracy Under Section 321

Section 321 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) creates the statutory offence of conspiracy to commit an offence. A conspiracy is an agreement between two or more persons to commit an offence. The offence is complete when the agreement is reached - the intended crime does not need to be carried out, attempted, or even commenced.

Two requirements must be proved beyond reasonable doubt:

  • There was an agreement between two or more persons to commit a specific offence.
  • The accused was a party to that agreement with a genuine intention to carry it out.

A genuine intention to complete the agreed offence is required. An agreement formed without any real intention to follow through does not constitute conspiracy. The penalty for conspiracy is determined by reference to the offence the accused conspired to commit - typically the same maximum as for that offence.

Section 321F(4) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) provides that an indictment charging conspiracy to cheat and defraud or conspiracy to defraud must not be filed without the approval of the Director of Public Prosecutions.

Incitement Under Section 321G

Section 321G of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) creates the offence of incitement. A person is guilty of incitement if they incite another person to commit an indictable offence. The offence is complete when the incitement occurs - the other person does not need to agree to commit the offence or to take any steps toward it.

Under s.321G, if the inciting is acted on in accordance with the inciter's intention, the inciter is guilty of the indictable offence of incitement. Where the incitement is not acted on, the inciter is still guilty of the offence of incitement. The penalty for incitement is determined by reference to the offence incited.

The prosecution must prove that the accused actively encouraged or urged another to commit the specific offence, and that the accused intended the other person to commit it. An expression of a wish or hope that a crime will occur, without active encouragement or urging, does not constitute incitement.

Accessory After the Fact

A person who assists an offender after a crime has been committed - for example by hiding them, assisting them to escape, or concealing evidence - may be charged as an accessory after the fact. This is a distinct category from secondary participation in the crime itself. An accessory after the fact is not liable as a principal offender; the penalties are generally lower than for the principal offence, though accessory after the fact to murder carries a significant maximum term.

The prosecution must prove that the accused knew a specific offence had been committed, and that they deliberately assisted the offender with the purpose of enabling them to evade justice.

Penalties

A person convicted as a secondary party to an offence (by aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring) faces the same maximum penalty as the principal offender. The maximum for any individual charge depends on the offence that was committed. Sentencing courts consider the degree of participation, the closeness to the offending, and whether the accused stood to benefit from the crime. A person who played a minor role as a lookout faces a different sentencing position from the person who conceived and directed the offence, even though both may be convicted of the same charge.

For conspiracy and incitement, the maximum penalty is typically the same as for the underlying offence the accused agreed to commit or encouraged.

Available Defences

Absence of Knowledge

Secondary liability requires proof that the accused knew the essential matters constituting the offence being committed. Where the accused did not know the offending was occurring, or did not know the nature of what they were assisting, the knowledge element fails. Wilful blindness - deliberately avoiding knowledge - may be treated as equivalent to knowledge in appropriate cases, but genuine ignorance is a defence.

Absence of Intent to Assist or Encourage

Presence at the scene of an offence, without intent to assist or encourage, does not make a person a secondary participant. Where the accused was present but had no intention to assist or encourage the principal, they are not criminally liable as a secondary party. The prosecution must establish actual intent, not merely that assistance was in fact provided.

Withdrawal

A person who has agreed to participate in a criminal enterprise may have a defence of withdrawal if they genuinely and completely withdraw from the enterprise before the offence is committed, and take reasonable steps to communicate that withdrawal to other participants. The law on what constitutes effective withdrawal is strictly applied. A change of mind without any communication to co-offenders, or a withdrawal after the offence has begun, is not generally effective.

No Agreement (for Conspiracy)

Conspiracy requires a genuine agreement between two or more persons. Where the accused was not a party to any agreement, or where no real agreement was formed, the conspiracy charge is not established. An undercover police officer posing as a co-conspirator does not provide a genuine second party to the agreement - the law on this point requires careful analysis in cases involving covert police operations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I be convicted of a crime I did not physically commit in Victoria? +
Yes. Victorian criminal law holds secondary participants liable for offences committed by others where they aided, abetted, counselled or procured the commission of the offence. A person convicted as a secondary party faces the same maximum penalty as the person who physically committed the offence. What must be proved is that the accused had knowledge of the essential elements of the offence and intended to assist or encourage it.
What is joint criminal enterprise? +
Joint criminal enterprise is a doctrine under which participants in an agreed criminal plan are each liable for offences committed in furtherance of that plan. In its extended form, confirmed in McAuliffe v The Queen (1995) 183 CLR 108 and reaffirmed in Miller v The Queen [2016] HCA 30, a participant is also liable for further offences committed by co-offenders during the enterprise where the participant foresaw those offences as a possible incident of carrying out the plan and continued to participate regardless. The doctrine remains good law in Australia; the United Kingdom abolished it in R v Jogee [2016] UKSC 8 and now requires proof of actual intent.
What is the difference between conspiracy and incitement? +
Conspiracy under s.321 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) is an agreement between two or more persons to commit an offence, with a genuine intention to carry it out. Incitement under s.321G is urging or encouraging another person to commit an indictable offence. Conspiracy requires a bilateral agreement; incitement is unilateral. Both are complete offences regardless of whether the intended crime is ever committed.
Does being present at a crime make me criminally responsible? +
Presence at the scene of a crime alone does not make a person criminally responsible as a secondary party. The prosecution must prove knowledge of the offending and an intention to assist or encourage it. Where presence was accidental or without any such knowledge or intent, no secondary liability arises. However, where presence was agreed in advance with a role to play, or where encouragement was given by being there, liability may be established.
Can I withdraw from a joint criminal enterprise? +
A person who has joined a joint criminal enterprise may have a defence of withdrawal if they genuinely and completely withdrew before the offence was committed and communicated that withdrawal clearly to the other participants. A change of mind without communication, or withdrawal after the offence has begun, does not typically qualify as effective withdrawal. Whether withdrawal was effective is assessed on the specific facts.
What is an accessory after the fact? +
An accessory after the fact is a person who, knowing that a specific offence has been committed, deliberately assists the offender to evade justice - by hiding them, helping them escape, or concealing evidence. An accessory after the fact is not liable as a principal offender and typically faces a lower maximum penalty than those who participated in the offence itself. The prosecution must prove actual knowledge that a specific offence had been committed.

Charged with an offence involving group criminal activity?

Speak with a criminal defence lawyer today - no cost, no obligation.
Call 1300 331 331
Scroll to Top
Call Now Contact
Us