The offence — section 15B of the Crimes Act 1958
Section 15B of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) provides that a person must not, without lawful excuse, recklessly cause serious injury to another person in circumstances of gross violence. The offence carries the same maximum penalty as recklessly causing serious injury under section 17 but attracts mandatory minimum non-parole periods that section 17 does not.
| Element | Detail |
| Legislation | Section 15B, Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) |
| Maximum penalty | Level 4 imprisonment — 15 years |
| Court | County Court or higher court — strictly indictable |
Circumstances of gross violence
The legislation sets out a specific list of circumstances that constitute gross violence. The presence of any one of them is sufficient to establish this element:
- The offender planned in advance to engage in the relevant conduct and at the time of planning intended to cause serious injury, was reckless as to whether serious injury would result, or a reasonable person would have foreseen that serious injury was a likely result
- The offender caused the serious injury in company with two or more other persons
- The offender participated in a joint criminal enterprise with two or more others in causing the injury
- The offender planned in advance to have and use an offensive weapon, firearm or imitation firearm, and in fact used it to cause the serious injury
- The offender continued to cause injury to the other person after that person was incapacitated
- The offender caused serious injury while the victim was already incapacitated
What the prosecution must prove
- Serious injury was caused — an injury that endangers life, is substantial and protracted, or involves the destruction of a foetus
- Recklessness — the accused was aware at the time of the conduct that it would probably cause serious injury to another person, and proceeded regardless
- Circumstances of gross violence — the prosecution must establish at least one of the six circumstances listed in the section
- Without lawful excuse — the accused acted without lawful justification or excuse
Available defences
- Self-defence — available where the accused genuinely believed their conduct was necessary to defend themselves or another and the response was reasonable in the circumstances as perceived by the accused
- Factual dispute — contesting whether the accused caused the injury alleged, or whether the circumstances of the offending satisfy any of the gross violence circumstances
- Identification dispute — where the prosecution cannot prove the accused was the person who committed the offence
- Lack of recklessness — contesting whether the accused was aware their conduct would probably cause serious injury, as opposed to merely being aware that injury was possible
- Mental impairment — available in appropriate circumstances under the Crimes (Mental Impairment and Unfitness to be Tried) Act 1997 (Vic)