The Common Law Offence
Public nuisance in Victoria is a common law offence - it is not defined in any Victorian statute. The offence derives from the English common law and is described as an act or omission that endangers the life, safety, health, property or comfort of the public, or that obstructs the public in the exercise or enjoyment of rights common to all members of the public. The maximum penalty is set by the table to section 320 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) at 5 years imprisonment.
The common law offence is an indictable offence heard in the County Court of Victoria. It is distinct from the summary public order offences in the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic), which are lower-level offences heard in the Magistrates' Court. In practice, many forms of conduct that could be charged as common law public nuisance are instead charged under the Summary Offences Act, which has lower maximum penalties but is more commonly used by police for public order incidents.
Elements of the Common Law Offence
The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that:
- The accused did an act or made an omissionThe accused performed a voluntary act or failed to perform an act they were under a legal duty to perform.
- The act or omission was of a public characterThe conduct affected or was capable of affecting the public generally - or a section of the public that was sufficiently large or indeterminate to constitute "the public" for the purposes of the offence. A private nuisance between neighbouring parties is not public nuisance.
- The conduct caused or was likely to cause a common injuryThe conduct endangered the life, safety, health, property or comfort of members of the public, or obstructed them in the exercise of a right common to all members of the public. Obstructing a public highway, polluting a public water supply, causing dangerous conditions in a public place, or creating an ongoing hazard to those using a public space have all founded charges of public nuisance at common law.
At common law, the prosecution does not need to prove that any individual member of the public was actually harmed. The risk or likelihood of harm to the public, or the substantial interference with public rights, is sufficient. Whether the conduct meets the threshold of public nuisance rather than merely offensive behaviour is a question of the degree of impact on the public.
Section 17 of the Summary Offences Act 1966: Offensive Behaviour
Section 17 of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic) creates several summary offences commonly charged in public order situations, distinct from the common law public nuisance offence. These include:
- s.17(1)(c): use of profane, indecent or obscene language, or threatening, abusive or insulting words, in or near a public place or within the view or hearing of a person in a public place.
- s.17(1)(d): behaving in a riotous, indecent, offensive or insulting manner in or near a public place or within the view or hearing of a person in a public place.
These are summary offences heard in the Magistrates' Court. The maximum penalty is 10 penalty units ($2,091.00 at the 2026-27 rate) or 2 months imprisonment for a first offence, increasing to 15 penalty units or 3 months imprisonment for a second offence, and 25 penalty units or 6 months imprisonment for a third or subsequent offence. The lower maximum reflects the less serious nature of these offences compared to the common law public nuisance offence, even though the underlying conduct may overlap.
Distinction Between Common Law Public Nuisance and Summary Offences
| Feature | Common law public nuisance | s.17 SOA 1966 (offensive behaviour) |
|---|---|---|
| Source | Common law, maximum in s.320 Crimes Act 1958 | Statute: Summary Offences Act 1966 s.17 |
| Maximum penalty | 5 years imprisonment | 10 penalty units ($2,091.00) or 2 months imprisonment (first offence); up to 25 penalty units or 6 months (third or subsequent offence) |
| Court | County Court of Victoria | Magistrates' Court of Victoria |
| Nature | Indictable | Summary |
| Scope | Conduct injurious to the public generally or a section of the public | Offensive, indecent, threatening or insulting conduct or language in or near a public place |
Common Examples
Conduct that has been charged as common law public nuisance in Australian jurisdictions includes:
- Obstructing a public road or footpath so as to prevent free passage by the public
- Causing a dangerous condition on public land that poses a risk to persons using it
- Creating excessive and sustained noise that substantially interferes with the comfort of persons in a neighbourhood
- Contaminating a public water source or other resource used by the public
- Operating a business in a manner that causes ongoing injury to the health of surrounding residents
Available Defences
No Public Character
The conduct must have affected the public or a sufficiently indeterminate section of the public. Where the alleged nuisance was limited to a defined and small group of private individuals rather than the public at large, the offence is not made out at common law. The distinction between a private nuisance and a public nuisance is one of scale and the identity of those affected.
No Common Injury
The conduct must have caused or been likely to cause a common injury to public health, safety, comfort, property or rights. Where the conduct was merely offensive to some persons without causing or threatening the required level of injury, the element may not be established. The threshold for public nuisance at common law is higher than for the s.17 summary offences.
Lawful Authority or Excuse
Where the conduct was authorised by law - for example, road works carried out under a statutory permit, or activities conducted under a licence or approval - the lawfulness of the activity may provide a defence. Where the obstruction or inconvenience caused is the necessary consequence of a lawfully authorised activity, the common law offence is not established.
Reasonable Excuse (for s.17 Offences)
For the summary offences under s.17 of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic), a reasonable excuse may be available depending on the specific circumstances. Whether particular conduct in context constitutes offensive behaviour in or near a public place involves an assessment of current community standards. The test is whether the conduct would wound the feelings or arouse anger, resentment or disgust in the mind of a reasonable person of ordinary sensibilities present at the scene, rather than a highly sensitive or a highly tolerant person.
Which Courts Hear These Matters
Common law public nuisance charges are heard in the County Court of Victoria on William Street Melbourne. Summary behaviour offences under s.17 of the Summary Offences Act 1966 are heard in the Magistrates' Court. In metropolitan Melbourne, summary public order matters are typically dealt with at Melbourne Magistrates' Court on William Street, or at the suburban courts for Broadmeadows, Dandenong, Ringwood, Sunshine, and Frankston, depending on where the incident occurred.