Section 84BI of the Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic) makes it an offence to give false or misleading information in a statutory nomination, the form used under Part 6AA to nominate the person who was driving when a speed camera offence was detected. Conviction triggers mandatory licence cancellation under s 84BIA. Courts have imposed imprisonment in a minority of matters. A fine is the most common outcome, but the mandatory cancellation consequence is unavoidable if convicted.
Charged under s 84BI? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation with a Victorian criminal defence lawyer.
Part 6AA of the Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic) establishes what is commonly called the "operator onus" system. When a speed camera detects a vehicle committing an offence, the infringement notice is initially sent to the registered operator of that vehicle, which is usually the registered owner. If the operator was not the driver at the time, they may nominate the person who was.
Section 84BE(1) gives the operator the power to nominate another person as the driver. Section 84BF(1)(a) allows the person nominated to respond, either accepting responsibility or providing information that they were not the driver. Section 84BI makes it an offence for either the nominating operator or the nominated person to provide false or misleading information in those statutory statements.
For excessive speed offences, the operator must nominate within 28 days of the infringement notice. For other camera-detected offences, s 84BE sets no fixed day limit; the nomination must be made before the infringement is registered with Fines Victoria. Operators who do not nominate a driver and who are found not to have been driving themselves may face a separate infringement for failing to nominate.
Section 84BI makes it an offence for a person to give, in a statement made under s 84BE(1) or s 84BF(1)(a), information that the person knows to be false or misleading in a material particular. The key word is "knows." The section requires actual subjective knowledge of the falsity. Carelessness, poor memory, or guessing incorrectly are not enough to establish the offence.
| Element | Detail |
|---|---|
| Legislation | s 84BI Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic) |
| Court | Magistrates' Court of Victoria |
| Maximum penalty (individual) | 60 penalty units ($12,546 at the 2026–27 rate) |
| Maximum penalty (body corporate) | 120 penalty units ($25,092 at the 2026–27 rate) |
| Licence consequence | Mandatory cancellation on conviction (s 84BIA) |
| Mandatory disqualification | Minimum 6 months under s 84BIA (court has discretion to impose longer) |
| Penalty unit value (2026–27) | $209.10 per unit |
The prosecution must establish beyond reasonable doubt that:
The knowledge element is the central battleground in most contested s 84BI matters. A prosecution that cannot prove the accused knew the nominated person was not actually the driver will fail, even if it can show the nomination was incorrect.
A material particular is a piece of information that is capable of affecting the outcome of the proceeding or the administration of the infringement scheme in a meaningful way. Nominating a person who did not drive is a false statement in a material particular because it redirects liability away from the actual driver. A clerical error in a middle name or a minor transposition in a date, that is not likely to cause confusion or affect the proceedings, is unlikely to meet the threshold.
Section 84BIA provides that if a person is found guilty of an offence against s 84BI, the court must cancel their licence or learner permit and disqualify them from obtaining a licence or permit for a minimum of six months. This consequence is mandatory. The court has no discretion to waive the cancellation or reduce the disqualification period below six months. The court may impose a longer period of disqualification if it considers the circumstances warrant it.
The mandatory cancellation applies to the person convicted, not to the person who was falsely nominated. Where a vehicle owner nominates a family member who did not actually drive, the owner faces the mandatory cancellation, not the nominee.
This is a consequence that many people do not anticipate when they file a nomination. The potential loss of licence for a minimum of six months on top of a significant fine makes this one of the more serious summary road safety offences from a practical standpoint.
Victoria's Sentencing Advisory Council recorded the following data for s 84BI charges sentenced in the Magistrates' Court between 2020 and 2023:
113 charges across 37 cases
Charges: fine 82.3% (93), community correction order 8.8% (10), adjourned undertaking 8.0% (9), imprisonment 0.9% (1).
Cases: fine 64.9% (24 of 37), community correction order 13.5% (5), adjourned undertaking 10.8% (4), imprisonment 10.8% (4).
Source: Sentencing Advisory Council Victoria, SACStat database.
Imprisonment arises in a small number of cases. Courts treat deliberate false nominations seriously because they obstruct the administration of the road safety infringement system and shift liability away from the actual driver. Where the false nomination was part of a deliberate scheme to avoid a drink driving charge or a further demerit point accumulation that would trigger disqualification, the court may treat that context as an aggravating factor.
The mandatory cancellation is relevant to the overall sentence because it already constitutes a significant consequence. Courts generally take that into account when calibrating the fine or other penalty alongside the mandatory order.
The following situations commonly give rise to s 84BI charges:
The prosecution must prove the accused knew the information was false. A vehicle owner who genuinely believed the nominated person was driving, and had reasonable grounds for that belief, has a defence. This commonly arises where the owner relied on a log or a verbal statement from the person they nominated, and that person later denied being the driver. The accused's honest belief, if it was reasonable, prevents the prosecution from establishing the knowledge element.
Fleet operators or vehicle owners with multiple potential drivers may genuinely be uncertain who was driving. Where the nomination was made on an honest, if incorrect, assessment of who was most likely to have been driving, and the owner cannot be shown to have known this was wrong, the charge may not be established.
A person who was coerced into making a false statement, under genuine threat of harm or other compulsion, may raise duress as a defence. The defence requires proof that the threat was serious, immediate, and not one that a person of ordinary firmness could be expected to resist.
If the information that was incorrect was not a material particular, the offence is not made out. Whether the inaccuracy was material is a factual question that depends on what effect, if any, the false or misleading information had on the administration of the infringement or the proceedings.
For excessive speed offences, the operator has 28 days from the date of the infringement notice to nominate another driver. For other camera-detected offences, there is no fixed day limit under s 84BE, but the nomination must be lodged before the infringement is registered with Fines Victoria. If you have already lodged a nomination and are now concerned about its accuracy, you should seek legal advice immediately rather than lodging further correspondence with Fines Victoria without understanding the legal implications of what you say.
Amending a nomination to correct a genuine error, before the matter has been prosecuted, may or may not provide a complete answer to a subsequent s 84BI charge depending on the circumstances. The timing of the correction and what you knew at the time of the original nomination are both relevant.