The Test for a No Case Submission
The test for a no case submission in Australia is whether, on the prosecution evidence taken at its highest, the accused could lawfully be convicted. This formulation derives from the High Court of Australia in May v O'Sullivan (1955) 92 CLR 654, where Dixon CJ, Webb, Fullagar, Kitto and Taylor JJ stated at 657-658:
"When, at the close of the case for the prosecution, a submission is made that there is 'no case to answer', the question to be decided is not whether on the evidence as it stands the defendant ought to be convicted, but whether on the evidence as it stands he could lawfully be convicted."
The distinction is critical. The question is not whether a conviction is likely or probable on the evidence. It is whether a conviction is legally possible on the evidence as it currently stands. Where the prosecution evidence, accepted in its entirety and given every favourable inference available to the prosecution, could not support a finding of guilt, the charge must be dismissed at that stage.
In Doney v The Queen (1990) 171 CLR 207, the High Court confirmed the test for jury trials: a judge is bound to direct an acquittal if there is no evidence upon which a reasonable jury could find the accused guilty. This is the test applied in the County Court and Supreme Court of Victoria where the matter is being tried by a jury.
When a No Case Submission Is Made
A no case submission is made after the prosecution has closed its case - that is, after the prosecution has called all its witnesses, tendered all its exhibits, and formally closed. The defence then applies to the court for the charge to be dismissed on the basis that the prosecution has not established a case sufficient to require an answer. The submission is made before the defence has opened or called any evidence.
In a jury trial in the County Court or Supreme Court, the no case submission is heard in the absence of the jury. The judge rules on the application without the jury being present. Where the submission succeeds, the judge directs the jury to return a verdict of not guilty. Where it fails, the jury is recalled and the defence may open its case and call evidence.
In a summary hearing in the Magistrates' Court, the no case submission is made to the Magistrate after the prosecution has closed. The Magistrate rules on whether the prosecution evidence is capable of supporting a finding of guilt. If the submission succeeds, the Magistrate dismisses the charge. If it fails, the defendant may give evidence and call witnesses.
Prosecution Evidence Taken at Its Highest
The no case submission is assessed by taking the prosecution evidence at its highest. This means the court treats the prosecution evidence in the most favourable way possible for the prosecution. Where a prosecution witness gave evidence that was both favourable and unfavourable to the prosecution, the most favourable version is taken. Where different inferences are available from the evidence, the court takes the inference most favourable to the prosecution.
Taking the prosecution evidence at its highest does not require the court to ignore inherent impossibilities or contradictions that make the evidence incapable of belief. Where the prosecution evidence, even taken at its highest, could not support a finding of guilt - because it does not establish an essential element of the offence, because it is internally contradictory to the point of being incapable of rational acceptance, or because no reasonable tribunal could find the accused guilty on it - the submission should succeed.
The court does not, on a no case submission, consider cross-examination evidence that contradicts the prosecution case or defence evidence. The focus is strictly on what the prosecution has established through its own case.
When a No Case Submission Should Be Made
A no case submission is appropriate where, at the close of the prosecution case, the prosecution has failed to establish one or more essential elements of the offence. Common situations in which no case submissions arise include:
- Where the prosecution has called no evidence of an essential element of the offence - for example, no evidence of the accused's identity as the person who committed the act charged
- Where the prosecution's only evidence on an element is so weak, vague or inherently improbable that no reasonable tribunal could act on it
- Where the key prosecution witness gave evidence that is so internally contradictory that it cannot rationally sustain a finding that the element is established
- Where the evidence called is legally incapable of establishing the offence charged - for example, because the conduct described does not satisfy the definition of the offence as a matter of law
The Difference Between a First Limb and Second Limb Submission
In summary proceedings, two distinct types of no case submission are recognised, sometimes called the first limb and second limb of the test in May v O'Sullivan.
- First limb (no prima facie case): The prosecution has called no evidence capable of supporting a finding of guilt on the charge as a matter of law. Where the first limb succeeds, the defendant is acquitted and the matter is at an end.
- Second limb (insufficient evidence to support conviction): The prosecution has called some evidence on all elements, but the evidence is so weak that it could not reasonably support a conviction. A second limb submission does not necessarily preclude the defendant from calling evidence if the submission fails - in practice, many Magistrates will ask the defendant whether they intend to call evidence before ruling on a second limb submission, since ruling on it when the defendant intends to call evidence is generally not appropriate.
In jury trials in the County Court and Supreme Court, the test from Doney v The Queen applies: whether there is evidence upon which a reasonable jury properly directed could convict. This corresponds broadly to the first limb test.
What Happens If the Submission Fails
Where a no case submission fails, the trial continues. In a jury trial, the jury is recalled. The defence may open its case, give an opening address, call the accused to give evidence (if the accused chooses to do so) and call other witnesses. The accused has no obligation to give evidence, and no adverse inference is drawn from the decision not to testify.
Where a no case submission fails in summary proceedings, the defendant may give evidence and call witnesses. The decision whether to give evidence after a failed no case submission is a matter for careful consideration with the defendant's lawyer, having regard to the strength of the prosecution case and the potential advantages and risks of giving evidence.
Where a no case submission fails and the accused is subsequently convicted, the correctness of the ruling on the no case submission is generally not a ground of appeal against conviction. An appeal against conviction is assessed on whether the verdict was unreasonable or could not be supported having regard to the evidence - a different and broader standard than the no case test.
Which Courts Hear No Case Submissions in Victoria
No case submissions are made in the court hearing the criminal proceeding. In the Magistrates' Court of Victoria, they are heard at Melbourne Magistrates' Court on William Street for metropolitan matters, and at Broadmeadows, Dandenong, Ringwood, Sunshine, Frankston, Geelong and Ballarat for outer metropolitan and regional matters. In indictable proceedings, they are heard in the County Court of Victoria on William Street Melbourne or in the Supreme Court of Victoria at 450 Little Bourke Street Melbourne.