Making False Statements Concerning Contamination of Goods (s.251 Crimes Act 1958) — Australian Criminal Lawyers
Victorian criminal law · Serious criminal offences

Charged With Making False Statements About Contamination of Goods?

Section 251 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) creates a specific offence targeting false statements about the contamination of goods — made with the intention of causing another person or the public to believe that goods have been contaminated, with intent to cause or recklessness as to causing public alarm or economic loss. Maximum penalty: 10 years imprisonment.

Facing a charge under section 251? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation — a social media post alleging contamination, sent with the requisite intent, can trigger this offence.

The Offence — Section 251 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic)

A person commits this offence if they make a statement they believe to be false, with the intention of causing another person or the public to believe that goods have been contaminated — and either intend to cause, or are reckless as to whether they cause, public alarm or anxiety, or economic loss arising from public awareness of the statement.

The law captures a wide range of conduct. Making a statement includes conveying information by any means — spoken words, written communications, social media posts, text messages, emails, and any other medium capable of transmitting information to another person or to the public. The offence does not require that any actual contamination occurred, nor that the statement was in fact believed.

Elements of the Offence

  1. The accused made a statement — communicated information to at least one other person by any mode of communication.
  2. The accused believed the statement to be false — a subjective element. The prosecution must prove the accused genuinely believed, at the time of making the statement, that it was untrue. A person who honestly believed their statement to be true cannot be found guilty.
  3. The statement was made with the intention of inducing belief in contamination — under s 248 of the Crimes Act, "contaminate" includes interfering with goods or merely making it appear that goods have been contaminated.
  4. The accused intended to cause, or was reckless as to causing, public alarm or economic loss — recklessness means the accused was aware of a substantial risk that public alarm or economic loss would result and proceeded regardless.

Maximum Penalty and Court

Maximum penalty: Level 5 imprisonment (10 years) or a Level 5 fine of up to 1,200 penalty units, or both. Cost recovery orders for emergency service costs are also available. The offence is heard in the County Court; it may be heard summarily in the Magistrates' Court with the accused's consent.

Possible Defences

Honest and Reasonable Belief

If the accused genuinely believed their statement to be true, the prosecution cannot establish the core element that the statement was known to be false.

Lack of Intent or Recklessness

Where the statement was made as genuine concern, a misunderstood joke, or in a clearly private context with no foreseeable public reach, the mental element may not be satisfied.

Factual Dispute

Challenging whether the accused made the relevant statement at all, or whether the communication amounted to a statement about contamination within the meaning of the section.

Facing a section 251 charge?

The mental elements of this charge are nuanced and highly fact-specific.
Call 1300 331 331
Scroll to Top
Call Now Contact
Us