The Offence
Section 49B of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic) provides that a person who is known or reputed to be a thief or known or reputed to have committed drug-related offences is guilty of an offence if they loiter in a public place while intending to commit an indictable offence and while loitering engage in conduct constituting a step toward the commission of the intended indictable offence. The maximum penalty is imprisonment for 2 years.
The offence is a preparatory offence. It does not require the intended indictable offence to have been completed, attempted, or even commenced in a formal sense. It targets conduct at an early stage of criminal preparation, in circumstances where the person's prior record or reputation brings them within the scope of the section.
The Four Elements
All four elements must be established by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt. The failure of any single element means the charge is not made out.
- Known or reputed thief or known or reputed to have committed drug-related offencesThe accused must be either known or reputed to be a thief, or known or reputed to have committed drug-related offences. A previous conviction is not required. Under s.49B(2) of the Act, the prosecution may adduce evidence to establish this element - a conviction is sufficient but not necessary. Where the prosecution relies solely on reputation evidence, the nature and basis of that reputation can be challenged in cross-examination.
- Loitering in a public placeThe accused was loitering in a public place at the relevant time. Loitering means being present in a location without a legitimate or apparent purpose connected to that location. Being in a public place for a lawful purpose - shopping, waiting for transport, meeting someone - is not loitering. "Public place" has the meaning given in s.3 of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic), which covers roads, footpaths, parks, licensed premises, and other places members of the public are present or permitted to be.
- Intent to commit an indictable offenceWhile loitering, the accused intended to commit an indictable offence. The prosecution need not identify a specific indictable offence by name or section - it is sufficient that the accused intended to commit some indictable offence. However, the prosecution must establish actual intent, not merely that the accused could have formed such an intent. Where a person was present for a wholly innocent reason and had no intention directed toward criminal activity, this element is not established. Physical presence, even by a person with relevant prior convictions, does not alone prove criminal intent.
- Conduct in furtherance of the intended offenceWhile loitering, the accused engaged in active conduct constituting a step toward committing the intended indictable offence. Passive presence is not enough. The conduct must represent an active step toward the offending - surveillance of premises, attempting to gain access, communicating with co-offenders about the planned conduct, or similar purposive acts. The connection between the conduct observed and the alleged criminal purpose must be established by the prosecution.
Evidence Under s.49B(2)
Section 49B(2) of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic) expressly provides that in proceedings for the offence, the prosecution may give or produce evidence to prove that the accused is a known or reputed thief or is known or reputed to have committed drug-related offences, and may also adduce evidence to rebut any evidence given by or on behalf of the accused, including evidence as to general character. The section allows any evidence going to that element, including prior convictions, police records, and reputation evidence.
Where the prosecution intends to rely on reputation evidence, the accused can challenge the basis and currency of the alleged reputation. The evidence must relate to the accused being known as a thief or as a person who has committed drug-related offences - evidence going only to bad character generally does not satisfy this element.
Prior convictions for theft or drug offences are the most direct way of establishing this element, but the section is not confined to convictions. Where the prosecution leads reputation evidence without convictions, the quality and source of that evidence can be tested. The admissibility and use of prior conviction evidence in criminal proceedings is also governed by the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic).
What "Loitering" Means
Loitering means being present in a public place without a legitimate or apparent purpose connected to that location. The concept requires the prosecution to show the accused was present without any evident lawful reason for being there at that time. A person who is in a public place for a recognisable purpose - shopping, commuting, meeting a person, attending a venue - is not loitering in that location, even if they have a criminal history.
Where the accused had a genuine, lawful purpose for being in the location - demonstrated by CCTV footage of purposeful movement, receipts, travel records, witness accounts, or testimony from the accused - the prosecution's case that the accused was loitering may be undermined. The burden remains on the prosecution to establish the element.
The Indictable Offence Requirement
The intended offence must be an indictable offence. Not all criminal offences are indictable. Summary offences heard only in the Magistrates' Court do not qualify. Indictable offences include burglary, robbery, theft, drug trafficking, and other offences of a serious nature that may be tried before a jury. Where the prosecution alleges the accused intended to commit a summary offence only, the third element is not established.
The prosecution does not need to identify a specific intended indictable offence by name or charge. Where it can be inferred from the accused's conduct, location, and the circumstances that the accused intended to commit some indictable offence, the element may be established. Where multiple possible inferences exist and not all of them involve an indictable offence, the prosecution's case is weaker.
Sentencing Outcomes in Practice
Magistrates' Court
Source: Sentencing Advisory Council of Victoria (SACStat), Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic) s 49B(1), Magistrates' Court, 1 July 2020 to 30 June 2023 - 112 charges across 105 cases.
Which Court Hears the Matter
Loitering with intent to commit an indictable offence is a summary offence heard in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria. Despite the 2-year maximum imprisonment term, which is higher than many indictable offences, the charge is a summary offence with no right of election for jury trial. In metropolitan Melbourne, matters are heard at Melbourne Magistrates' Court on William Street. Depending on where the alleged loitering occurred, the matter may also be listed at Broadmeadows Magistrates' Court, Dandenong Magistrates' Court, Ringwood Magistrates' Court, Sunshine Magistrates' Court, or Frankston Magistrates' Court.
Available Defences
Lawful Purpose in the Location
Where the accused had a genuine, lawful purpose for being present at the relevant location at the relevant time, the loitering element fails. A person shopping in a location, waiting for transport, attending a venue, or passing through for a recognisable purpose is not loitering. Evidence of lawful purpose can be established through CCTV footage, receipts, travel records, or testimony. The prosecution must prove loitering - the accused need not prove innocence, but evidence of a lawful purpose directly contests this element.
Absence of Intent
The intent element is a mental state that the prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt. Prior convictions, reputation, and presence in a location associated with criminal activity do not by themselves establish intent to commit an indictable offence on the occasion charged. Where the accused had no specific criminal purpose at the relevant time, the third element is not established. The prosecution must point to evidence of actual intent, not merely the possibility that an intent could have existed.
No Conduct in Furtherance
The fourth element requires active conduct constituting a step toward committing the intended offence. Passive standing or movement without any purposive act directed toward an offence is not enough. Where the accused's conduct in the location is consistent with innocent purposes, the prosecution's attempt to characterise it as conduct in furtherance of an indictable offence can be challenged. The connection between what the accused was observed doing and any alleged criminal purpose must be drawn from specific conduct, not from general suspicion.
First Element Not Established
Where the prosecution's evidence does not establish that the accused is known or reputed to be a thief, or known or reputed to have committed drug-related offences, the first element fails. Evidence going only to general bad character, or to other kinds of offending unrelated to theft or drugs, does not satisfy this element. Where the prosecution relies on reputation evidence that is remote, unreliable, or does not specifically go to theft or drug-related offending, the currency and adequacy of that evidence can be contested. Where the prosecution relies solely on a prior conviction that is old or does not relate to theft or drugs, the same challenge applies.
Identification Dispute
The prosecution must prove the accused was the person who was loitering at the relevant location. Where the prosecution relies on CCTV footage, police observations, or witness accounts to identify the accused, those forms of identification evidence can be challenged. The reliability of identification evidence is always a live issue in contested hearings.
Police Interviews and This Charge
A police interview is not typically an opportunity to explain your side of the story. In many cases by the time of interview, police have already gathered evidence and will be seeking admissions or surrounding facts to use in proceedings. Any admission made in a police interview can be used as evidence in court. Legal advice before any police interview in relation to a charge under s.49B is important. The right to silence applies: under s.89 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), an unfavourable inference may not be drawn from evidence that the accused failed or refused to answer questions or respond to representations put to them by investigating officials.