The Statutory Framework
Prior to 1 July 2017, the predecessor to the current provisions was the old section 34B, which was inserted into the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) on 1 July 2005 by section 185 of the Cemeteries and Crematoria Act 2003 (Vic). That old section was repealed by section 3 of the Crimes Amendment (Sexual Offences) Act 2016 (No. 47/2016), which came into operation on 1 July 2017. The current provisions - ss.34B, 34BA, 34BB, 34BC, 34BD and 34BE - were inserted by the same amending Act. For conduct alleged to have occurred before 1 July 2017, the prosecution must proceed under the old s.34B as it existed at that time.
The current provisions separate the different forms of proscribed conduct into distinct offences, introduce a specific no-mistaken-belief rule, confirm that the location of the remains is immaterial, and provide a set of statutory exceptions for professional and scientific activities.
Section 34B: Sexual Activity with the Corpse of a Human Being
Section 34B creates the offence of sexual activity with the corpse of a human being. The prosecution must prove that the accused intentionally engaged in a sexual activity with the corpse of a human being.
"Sexual activity" for the purposes of s.34B is defined by the Act itself: an activity is sexual if it would constitute sexual penetration as defined by section 35A of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) if the corpse were a living person.
The maximum penalty for an offence against s.34B is level 6 imprisonment - 5 years maximum.
Section 34BE provides that it is not a defence to an offence against s.34B that the accused had an honest and reasonable belief that the activity in which they engaged was not sexual. Where an activity meets the definition of sexual activity in the Act, the accused's belief about its character is irrelevant.
Section 34BA: Removal of Body Parts from the Corpse of a Human Being
Section 34BA creates the offence of removing body parts from the corpse of a human being. The prosecution must prove that the accused intentionally removed body parts from the corpse of a human being.
The maximum penalty for an offence against s.34BA is level 6 imprisonment - 5 years maximum.
Where a legitimate medical, scientific or professional purpose exists, the exceptions in s.34BD may apply. The offence does not require proof of any sexual or indecent purpose.
Section 34BB: Offensive Conduct Involving Human Remains
Section 34BB creates the offence of offensive conduct involving human remains. It applies where a person engages in conduct involving human remains that is offensive.
The maximum penalty for an offence against s.34BB is level 6 imprisonment - 5 years maximum.
Section 34BE provides that it is not a defence to an offence against s.34BB that the accused had an honest and reasonable belief that the conduct was not offensive. Section 34BE makes clear that the accused's honest and reasonable belief that the conduct was not offensive is not a defence.
Section 34BE expressly provides that it is not a defence to an offence against s.34BB that the accused held an honest and reasonable belief that their conduct was not offensive.
Section 34BC: Location of the Corpse or Human Remains is Immaterial
Section 34BC provides that for the purposes of ss.34B, 34BA and 34BB, the location of the corpse or human remains is immaterial. An offence under any of these three provisions can be committed wherever the corpse or remains are located - whether in a mortuary, a public space, a private building, or elsewhere. The geographic circumstances of where the conduct occurs do not affect whether the offence is made out.
Section 34BD: Exceptions
Section 34BD provides statutory exceptions to ss.34B, 34BA and 34BB. The exceptions are directed at conduct carried out in the context of legitimate medical, scientific, educational, public health, and other recognised professional activities.
The exceptions under s.34BD apply to all three offences: ss.34B, 34BA and 34BB.
Whether a specific activity falls within the s.34BD exceptions depends on the facts of the case, including the nature of the activity, the context in which it was carried out, and whether it was performed for a legitimate recognised purpose. Activities that are ostensibly professional in nature but carried out for improper purposes do not attract the exception.
Penalty Summary
| Offence | Provision | Maximum penalty |
|---|---|---|
| Sexual activity with corpse | s.34B Crimes Act 1958 | Level 6 - 5 years maximum |
| Removal of body parts from corpse | s.34BA Crimes Act 1958 | Level 6 - 5 years maximum |
| Offensive conduct involving human remains | s.34BB Crimes Act 1958 | Level 6 - 5 years maximum |
What the Prosecution Must Prove
For any of the three offences, the prosecution must establish each element beyond reasonable doubt.
- The accused acted intentionallyAll three offences require intentional conduct. A person who handled remains in a professional context, inadvertently, or without any relevant purpose does not satisfy this element. The prosecution must prove the accused deliberately engaged in the proscribed conduct.
- The conduct falls within the relevant offenceFor s.34B, the prosecution must establish that the activity would constitute sexual penetration under s.35A if the corpse were a living person. For s.34BA, that body parts were removed. For s.34BB, that the conduct was offensive involving human remains.
- The s.34BD exceptions do not applyWhere the accused raises conduct falling within the s.34BD exceptions, whether that conduct falls within the exceptions is assessed on the specific facts of the case, including the nature of the activity and its purpose.
Available Defences
Conduct Within the Section 34BD Exceptions
Where the conduct was carried out for a legitimate medical, scientific, educational, public health or other recognised professional purpose within the scope of s.34BD, that provides a complete answer to the charge. Medical practitioners, morticians, forensic pathologists, anatomists, and researchers who handle human remains in the course of their professional activities may rely on this exception where the conduct and its purpose fall within s.34BD. Whether the specific conduct is within the exception depends on what was done, why, and in what professional context.
Absence of Intentional Conduct
All three offences require intentional acts. Where the accused handled human remains inadvertently, or where the conduct was accidental rather than deliberate, the intent element is not established. This may arise in professional settings where contact with remains occurs in the normal course of a legitimate activity.
Factual Dispute
The prosecution must prove the conduct occurred and that it involved the remains of a human being. Where either fact is genuinely disputed, that is a matter for the evidence at trial. Forensic, surveillance, and witness evidence may all be relevant to establishing or contesting what occurred.
Note on Mistaken Belief
Section 34BE removes the honest and reasonable belief defence for both s.34B (belief that the activity was not sexual) and s.34BB (belief that the conduct was not offensive). An accused cannot rely on their genuine but mistaken belief about the character of their own conduct. This limits the scope of mistake of fact arguments for these two offences. The position under s.34BA is governed by the general principles applicable to intentional conduct offences.
Which Courts Hear the Matter
Offences under ss.34B, 34BA and 34BB are indictable offences. As indictable offences carrying a maximum of 5 years imprisonment, they may be heard in the Magistrates' Court where the parties consent to summary jurisdiction, or in the County Court. In metropolitan Melbourne, County Court matters are heard at William Street. Magistrates' Court matters may be heard at Melbourne Magistrates' Court on William Street, or at the Broadmeadows, Dandenong, Ringwood, Sunshine, or Frankston Magistrates' Courts depending on where the alleged conduct occurred.