False Info to Tax Officers – s 57 TAA 1997 Victoria
Victorian criminal law · Tax offences

Giving False or Misleading Information to Tax Officers

Section 57 of the Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic) makes it a criminal offence to intentionally give a tax officer information that is false or misleading. It applies to statements made orally or in writing and carries maximum penalties of $125,460 for corporations and $25,092 for individuals as at 2026-27.

Investigated or charged under s 57 of the TAA? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation. What you say to investigators can significantly affect the outcome of your matter.

The Offence and Its Legislative Context

Section 57 of the Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic) creates a stand-alone criminal offence of intentionally providing false or misleading information to a tax officer. For the purposes of s 57, a "tax officer" means the Commissioner of State Revenue, an authorised officer appointed under the Act, or any other person engaged in the administration or execution of a Victorian taxation law.

The offence is distinct from s 52 of the Act, which targets the integrity of required records themselves. Section 57 concerns the act of communication: a false or misleading statement conveyed to a tax officer, whether in response to a question under s 86 of the Act, in a return, in a statutory declaration, or in any other form of communication with the Commissioner or an authorised officer. The SRO administers this provision across payroll tax, land tax, duties, and all other taxation laws within its jurisdiction.

The provision is deliberately broad. It covers voluntary statements and compelled answers alike. It applies during formal and informal audit interviews, in correspondence, in returns lodged under the taxation laws, and in any other context where a person communicates information to someone acting in a tax officer capacity.

Maximum Penalties

The penalty unit value for 2026-27 is $209.10. The maximum penalties under s 57 are:

Defendant typePenalty unitsMaximum fine
Body corporate600$125,460
Any other person120$25,092

This offence is heard in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria. Upon conviction, a court may impose a fine or a Community Corrections Order. The higher corporate penalty reflects the legislature's view that deliberate corporate deception of the tax authority is a more serious matter than individual non-compliance.

What the Prosecution Must Prove

The prosecution must establish each of the following elements beyond reasonable doubt:

  1. The accused gave information to a tax officer The communication was directed to the Commissioner, an authorised officer appointed under the Act, or another person engaged in administering a Victorian taxation law.
  2. The information was false or misleading The statement was incorrect or inaccurate in a material way, one that relates to something capable of affecting the Commissioner's assessment or administrative decision. A trivial or entirely immaterial inaccuracy does not meet this threshold.
  3. The accused gave the information intentionally This is the critical mental element. Section 57 is not a strict liability or negligence offence. The prosecution must prove the accused knew the information was false or misleading at the time it was given and gave it deliberately. An honest mistake, however careless, does not satisfy this element.

Understanding "False or Misleading"

Information is false if it does not reflect the true position. Information is misleading if, while not strictly untrue in every particular, it creates a false impression by omitting material context, by framing accurate facts in a way that causes an incorrect inference, or by answering questions in a technically true but practically deceptive manner.

The offence is not limited to quantitative misstatements. A false statement about ownership, control, residency, the nature of a transaction, or any other material fact relevant to a taxation law can found a charge under s 57. Both oral and written communications are equally within scope.

Section 57 requires proof of intent. The prosecution must establish the accused knew the information was false or misleading at the time they gave it. An honest mistake is not an offence.

The Interview Context and the Risk of s 57 Exposure

Many s 57 charges arise from statements made to authorised officers during SRO audits or investigations. Under s 86 of the Act, an authorised officer who has lawfully entered premises and produced their identity card may require any person to answer questions, give information, produce documents, and provide reasonable assistance.

A person who gives false or misleading information in response to such a requirement commits an offence under s 57. This gives the provision significant practical reach: anyone who attends an SRO interview and provides inaccurate answers faces live criminal exposure if the inaccuracy was intentional. Legal advice before attending any such interview is strongly advisable.

It is equally important to understand that silence is not always available as a shield. Section 86 imposes a duty to answer questions in certain circumstances, and refusal or failure without a reasonable excuse may itself give rise to a separate offence under s 88 (obstruction). The interplay between these provisions underscores the importance of obtaining properly informed legal advice before engaging with investigators.

Available Defences

Absence of Intent

The most fundamental defence to a s 57 charge is that the accused did not intentionally provide false or misleading information. Where the inaccuracy arose from a genuine misunderstanding, a miscalculation, reliance on incorrect accounting advice, or a misreading of records, and the accused honestly believed what they said was true, the intent element is not established. The plausibility of this defence is assessed against all of the evidence, including the pattern of prior conduct and the degree of attention to detail expected of the accused.

The Information Was Not False or Misleading

Where the prosecution's characterisation of the information as false or misleading is itself disputed, the accused may challenge whether the statement was in fact incorrect. This may require expert accounting evidence about the correct treatment of a particular transaction, or reliance on documentary records demonstrating the statement reflected the true position at the time.

The Recipient Was Not a Tax Officer

Section 57 applies only where information was given to a person who qualifies as a tax officer within the meaning of the Act. If the recipient was a third-party contractor with no appointment as an authorised officer and no involvement in administering a taxation law, the offence is not made out. This is a fact-specific argument requiring analysis of who was present, in what capacity, and under what authority.

Sentencing Considerations

For those convicted of or pleading guilty to a s 57 offence, relevant sentencing factors include the degree of planning involved, the financial impact on the revenue, whether early admissions were made, the accused's prior compliance history, and whether remediation steps were taken before or after charge. A well-prepared plea hearing with character references, an accountant's report where relevant, and evidence of corrective steps can significantly affect the penalty imposed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I be charged under s 57 for an error in my tax return? +
An honest mistake, even a significant one, does not constitute an offence under s 57. The offence requires proof beyond reasonable doubt that the information was given intentionally, knowing it to be false or misleading. If you made an error you genuinely believed was accurate at the time, that is not a criminal offence. Civil penalty tax and interest may still apply under the non-criminal provisions of the Act, but the criminal prosecution requires proof of intent.
Does s 57 apply to verbal statements as well as written ones? +
Yes. Section 57 applies to information given to a tax officer whether orally or in writing. Statements made during audit meetings, answers given to questions under s 86, and verbal representations to authorised officers are all within scope. This is why any interaction with SRO investigators warrants legal advice beforehand, as the risk of s 57 exposure is real in both formal and informal settings.
What is the difference between s 52 and s 57 of the TAA? +
Section 52 addresses the integrity of records: it is an offence to make or keep a required taxation record containing false or misleading information. Section 57 addresses the act of communication: it is an offence to give false or misleading information to a tax officer, orally or in writing. A person may face charges under both provisions where they maintain false records and then communicate the false information in those records to an investigator. Each charge requires separate proof of its elements.
What should I do if I am contacted by the SRO about a possible audit? +
Seek legal advice before responding to any SRO contact that relates to a possible audit, investigation, or allegation of non-compliance. Authorised officers have broad investigative powers under Part 9 of the Act, but those powers are governed by specific requirements including identification obligations. A lawyer can advise you on what you are and are not required to say, identify any privilege that applies, and can accompany you to any formal interview.
If I voluntarily correct a false statement, does that affect my liability? +
A voluntary correction made promptly and before investigators have independently identified the error is a significant mitigating factor at sentencing. It does not extinguish criminal liability if the other elements of s 57 are established, but it weighs heavily in the accused's favour. The weight given depends on the timing, whether any outstanding tax was also paid, and the circumstances surrounding the original false statement.
Can a company and its director both be charged for the same false statement? +
Yes. Where a body corporate gives false or misleading information through an officer or employee, the corporation itself may be charged under s 57. Additionally, under s 130B of the Act, an officer of the body corporate involved in management may be personally liable if the offence was committed with their consent or connivance, or through their failure to exercise due diligence to prevent it. Corporate and individual proceedings are legally independent and may proceed concurrently.

Charged with giving false or misleading information to a Victorian tax officer?

Free consultation. Speak with a criminal defence lawyer before your next step.
Call 1300 331 331
Scroll to Top
Call Now Contact
Us