Failure to Answer Questions When Attending Before the Commissioner — Australian Criminal Lawyers
Commonwealth criminal law · Taxation offences

Failure to Answer Questions Before the Tax Commissioner

Section 8D of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) is a strict liability offence — the prosecution does not need to prove you intended to break the law. And unlike a standard police interview, the right to silence is largely abrogated in formal taxation hearings. The failure to answer is, in itself, the crime.

Charged with failure to answer questions before the Tax Commissioner? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation — a formal taxation hearing is a high-stakes legal event.

What the law states — section 8D

Section 8D of the Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) creates a criminal offence for failing to provide information during a formal attendance before the Commissioner of Taxation or an authorised officer. It is divided into three key prohibitions: refusal to answer a question when required by a taxation law; refusal to produce a book, paper, record, or document; and refusal to take an oath or make an affirmation when required.

Strict liability

A critical feature of section 8D is that it operates as a strict liability offence. The prosecution does not need to prove that you intended to break the law or that you acted with a guilty mind. They only need to prove the physical act occurred — that you were asked a question and did not answer.

Maximum penalties

Offence tierMaximum penalty
First offence20 penalty units (approx. $6,600 at 2026 Commonwealth rates)
Second or subsequent offence40 penalty units or imprisonment

What the prosecution must prove

  1. Requirement to attendYou were served with a valid notice to attend before the Commissioner or an authorised officer.
  2. The failureYou were asked a specific question or required to produce a specific document and failed to do so.
  3. The oathYou were required to take an oath or affirmation and refused.

The privilege against self-incrimination

In standard criminal law, the right to silence protects accused persons. In federal taxation matters, section 8D effectively abrogates the privilege against self-incrimination. You generally cannot refuse to answer a question simply because the answer might lead to a tax liability or a penalty. While the answer itself may attract use immunity — meaning it cannot be used against you in certain criminal proceedings — the failure to answer is, in itself, a crime.

Possible defences

  • Incapacity — section 8D(1B) — the law does not apply if you were not capable of complying, for example if the document requested was destroyed or the information is physically impossible for you to obtain
  • Invalid notice — if the original notice was not issued in strict accordance with the law, the requirement to answer may be void
  • Honest and reasonable mistake of fact — where you held an honest and reasonable belief in a state of facts which, if true, would have made your conduct lawful

Which court and sentencing

Although this is a federal offence, it is typically heard in the Magistrates' Court exercising federal jurisdiction. For first-time offenders, a primary goal is often to avoid a criminal conviction. Under section 19B of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) — the federal equivalent of a without-conviction order — the court can find the charge proven but dismiss it without recording a conviction.

Required to attend before the Tax Commissioner or facing a section 8D charge?

Get legal advice immediately — free consultation, no obligation.
Call 1300 331 331
Scroll to Top
Call Now Contact
Us