The Offences Under Section 479C
Section 479C of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) contains several distinct escape-related offences. All carry a maximum of level 6 imprisonment - 5 years.
Section 479C(1): Escape from Prison or Police Gaol
Section 479C(1) provides that a prisoner who escapes from a prison or a police gaol is guilty of an indictable offence punishable on conviction by level 6 imprisonment - 5 years maximum. The offence requires that the person is a prisoner, that they were held in a prison or police gaol, and that they escaped from it. "Prison" and "police gaol" have their meanings under the Corrections Act 1986 (Vic) and related legislation.
Section 479C(2): Failure to Return When Authorised to Be Absent
Section 479C(2) provides that a prisoner who is authorised to be absent from a prison under the Corrections Act 1986 (Vic) and who:
- (a) does not return to prison when the instrument of authority expires or when otherwise required by the instrument to do so; or
- (b) is required by the instrument authorising the absence to be under the supervision of another person and wilfully ceases to be under that supervision; or
- (c) does not return to prison upon being informed by an officer of the Office of Corrections or a police officer that the instrument authorising the absence has been revoked,
is guilty of an indictable offence punishable on conviction by level 6 imprisonment - 5 years maximum. This limb covers prisoners on authorised leave who fail to return or breach the conditions of their leave.
Section 479C(3): Wilfully Ceasing to Be in Custody Outside Prison
Section 479C(3) provides that a prisoner who is outside a prison or a police gaol but in custody and who wilfully ceases to be in custody is guilty of an indictable offence punishable on conviction by level 6 imprisonment - 5 years maximum. Section 479C(4) provides that for the purposes of s.479C(3), "prisoner" includes a person who is in the custody of a court.
This limb covers situations where a prisoner is being transported between custodial facilities, is attending court, or is otherwise outside the physical confines of a prison but remains legally in custody. A prisoner being transported who breaks free from custodial officers commits the offence under this subsection. A person remanded in custody who flees while being brought before the court also falls within s.479C(3) by reason of s.479C(4).
The Wilfulness Requirement
Each limb of s.479C requires wilful conduct. A prisoner who is accidentally released due to an administrative error, or who leaves a location because they were directed to do so by a person they reasonably believed had authority to direct them, does not commit the offence. The escape must be a deliberate, intentional act of the accused. Negligent or inadvertent departure from custody is not sufficient.
Lawfulness of Custody
The custody from which the accused escapes must be lawful. Where a person is held in unlawful custody - custody without a legal basis - escaping from it does not constitute the offence under s.479C. Whether custody was lawful is assessed objectively by reference to the legal authority under which it was imposed. Where the custody was unlawful, the accused may have a complete defence to the escape charge. However, the appropriate response to unlawful custody is ordinarily to seek release through legal means rather than by escape, and a court will scrutinise closely any claim that the accused genuinely believed their custody was unlawful at the time of the escape.
Evidentiary Provision: Section 479C(5)
Section 479C(5) provides that evidence that a prisoner has, without reasonable excuse, left a cell, or attempted to avoid detection by officers at a prison or police gaol, is evidence that the prisoner is attempting to escape from the prison or police gaol. This provision assists the prosecution by treating unexplained cell departures and attempts to avoid detection as circumstantial evidence of an attempt to escape, without requiring direct proof of an intention to leave the facility altogether.
Related Offences
Section 479A: Rescuing a Prisoner by Force
Section 479A of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) provides that any person who, by force, rescues or attempts to rescue from lawful custody any prisoner is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to level 5 imprisonment - 10 years maximum. This is significantly more serious than the escape offences under s.479C. The rescue offence requires the use of force. It is directed at third parties who intervene to free a prisoner by force, including the threat of force. Organised attempts to rescue prisoners - particularly those involving multiple participants or premeditation - are treated as especially serious.
Section 479B: Conveying Things to Prisoners to Facilitate Escape
Section 479B of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) makes it an offence to convey anything, or cause anything to be conveyed, to a prison or to a prisoner, with the intent to facilitate the escape of the prisoner. The maximum penalty is level 6 imprisonment - 5 years. The offence covers a broad range of assistance, including providing tools, weapons, communications equipment or other materials that could facilitate escape. The assistance may be provided directly to the prisoner or indirectly through third parties. The prosecution must prove that the assistance was provided with the specific intent to facilitate escape.
Available Defences
Absence of Wilfulness
Where the accused did not wilfully cease to be in custody - where the departure from custody was accidental, involuntary, or occurred in circumstances outside the accused's control - the wilfulness element is not established. The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt that the cessation of custody was wilful.
Unlawful Custody
Where the custody from which the accused escaped was not lawful - for example, where there was no valid warrant or legal authority for the detention - the accused may argue that the element of lawful custody is not established. This defence requires establishing the unlawfulness of the custody at the time of the escape.
Duress
The defence of duress may be available where the accused escaped because of threats of immediate death or serious injury, which at the time they reasonably believed could not otherwise be avoided and which a person of ordinary firmness and good character could not be expected to resist. Duress is available as a defence to an escape charge in limited circumstances: it does not apply where the accused had a safe avenue of escape from the threat, or where the threat was not operative at the time of the escape. The defence does not justify an indefinite absence - a person relying on duress must surrender to custody as soon as the threat has passed.
Which Courts Hear the Matter
Escaping from lawful custody under s.479C is an indictable offence. It may be heard summarily in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria where the parties consent, or in the County Court of Victoria on William Street Melbourne. Committal proceedings take place in the Magistrates' Court where the accused was held - Melbourne Magistrates' Court on William Street for prisoners held in metropolitan facilities, and the relevant regional Magistrates' Courts for Geelong, Ballarat or other regional matters. Rescue charges under s.479A proceed to the County Court on indictment given the 10-year maximum.