The Statutory Framework
Character evidence in Victorian criminal proceedings is governed by Part 3.8 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic), specifically sections 110, 111 and 112. These provisions apply only in criminal proceedings. There is no equivalent mechanism for adducing character evidence without restriction in civil proceedings.
The central mechanism in s.110 disapplies the four major exclusionary rules - the hearsay rule, the opinion rule, the tendency rule and the credibility rule - for evidence adduced by a defendant to prove good character. Without s.110, evidence of an accused's reputation or prior consistent behaviour would often be inadmissible under one or more of those rules. Section 110 cuts through those restrictions and permits the evidence to be adduced freely by the defence.
Section 110: Evidence About the Character of an Accused
Good Character Evidence by the Defence (s.110(1))
Section 110(1) of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) provides that the hearsay rule, the opinion rule, the tendency rule and the credibility rule do not apply to evidence adduced by a defendant to prove - directly or by implication - that the defendant is, either generally or in a particular respect, a person of good character.
Good character evidence can be adduced in two ways:
- Generally: evidence that the defendant is a person of good character overall - that they are honest, law-abiding, or of good reputation in their community.
- In a particular respect: evidence that the defendant is of good character in a specific aspect that is directly relevant to the charge - for example, evidence of non-violence in a charge involving violence, or evidence of financial probity in a fraud charge.
Good character evidence typically takes the form of testimony from family members, friends, employers, colleagues or community members who speak to the accused's reputation or to specific aspects of their conduct and disposition. It may also arise by implication from the circumstances - for example, where an accused gives evidence that they have no criminal convictions, this implies good character and engages s.110.
Rebuttal of General Good Character (s.110(2))
Section 110(2) provides that where evidence has been admitted to prove - directly or by implication - that a defendant is generally a person of good character, the hearsay rule, the opinion rule, the tendency rule and the credibility rule do not apply to evidence adduced to prove - directly or by implication - that the defendant is not generally a person of good character.
Once general good character is raised by the defence, the prosecution is entitled to adduce rebuttal evidence attacking that general character. The prosecution's rebuttal evidence enjoys the same freedom from the four exclusionary rules as the defence's original evidence. Importantly, the prosecution's rebuttal is not confined to rebutting specific aspects raised by specific witnesses - it can attack the defendant's general character by any permissible means.
Rebuttal of Character in a Particular Respect (s.110(3))
Section 110(3) provides that where evidence has been admitted to prove that a defendant is a person of good character in a particular respect, the prosecution's rebuttal evidence is limited to evidence going to that same particular respect. If the defence raised only the accused's non-violence, the prosecution may only rebut the character evidence in relation to violence. It cannot use the opening of character in a particular respect to attack the defendant's general character or character in other unrelated respects.
This limitation makes the distinction between general and particular character evidence practically significant. Where a defendant raises good character only in a particular respect, they limit the prosecution's avenue of rebuttal to that same respect. Where they raise general good character, they open a broader field for prosecution rebuttal.
Section 111: Character of Co-Accused
Section 111 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) governs the position where one accused raises character evidence in proceedings involving more than one accused. Where one defendant raises character and another does not, the jury must be directed not to draw any adverse inference against the defendant who has remained silent on the question of character. The character evidence of one accused does not operate against a co-accused who has not raised their own character.
Section 112: Leave Required for Prosecution Cross-Examination
Section 112 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) requires the prosecution to obtain leave of the court before cross-examining a defendant about matters that would tend to establish that the defendant is not of good character. Leave is not required where the defendant has already put their character in issue under s.110. The leave requirement under s.112, read with the balancing factors in s.192, gives the court a gatekeeping function over the prosecution's cross-examination on character.
Section 192 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) sets out the factors the court must consider when deciding whether to grant leave, including the extent to which the application would be unfair to a party or witness, the importance of the evidence, and the nature of the proceeding.
Where a defendant has raised good character - whether generally or in a particular respect - the prosecution does not need separate leave under s.112 to cross-examine on character in the relevant respect. The opening of character by the defence effectively grants permission for rebuttal within the scope of what was raised.
The Two Directions to the Jury
Where good character evidence is admitted at trial, the trial judge will typically give the jury a direction on how to use it. The direction has two limbs, each serving a distinct purpose:
- The credibility limb: where the defendant has given evidence, good character evidence goes to the credibility of that evidence. The jury may take the defendant's good character into account in assessing whether their evidence should be accepted.
- The propensity limb: good character makes it less likely that the defendant committed the offence charged. A person of good character is, by reason of that character, less likely to have done the act alleged.
Whether one or both limbs are given depends on whether the defendant gave evidence. Where the defendant did not give evidence, the credibility limb has no application. Both limbs may be available where the defendant gave evidence and adduced good character evidence.
The Victorian Criminal Charge Book (maintained by the Judicial College of Victoria) provides the standard directions that judges use when summing up on good character. Both limbs represent real instructions to the jury about how to use the evidence, not merely formalities.
What Constitutes Good Character Evidence
Good character evidence in Victorian criminal proceedings includes:
- Evidence from character witnesses who speak to the accused's reputation for specific traits - honesty, peacefulness, financial probity - relevant to the charge.
- Evidence from people who know the accused personally and speak to their disposition and conduct over time.
- Evidence that the accused has no prior criminal convictions - though the absence of convictions is not necessarily equivalent to positive good character and may or may not call for both jury directions depending on the circumstances.
- Evidence arising by implication from the accused's own testimony.
The weight given to good character evidence is a matter for the jury. Its value depends on the specificity of the evidence, the directness of its relevance to the charge, and whether the witness has genuine knowledge of the accused's character in the relevant respect.
Strategic Considerations
The decision to adduce good character evidence is a strategic one that requires careful analysis. Once raised, it invites prosecution rebuttal. If the defendant has prior criminal convictions that are not yet before the court, raising good character may open the door to those convictions being placed before the jury under s.110(2) or (3). An advance ruling under s.192A of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) can be sought before trial to determine whether the prosecution would be permitted to lead rebuttal evidence if good character is raised, allowing the defence to make an informed decision.
In Melbourne v The Queen (1999) 198 CLR 1, the High Court held that a trial judge is not obliged as a matter of law to give a good character direction to the jury, though where good character has been deliberately raised it would ordinarily be appropriate to do so. The direction, if given, may cover one or both limbs depending on the circumstances of the case.