Contempt of court in Victoria is primarily a common law offence. It covers conduct in the courtroom, breach of court orders, publication that prejudices proceedings, and interference with witnesses or jurors. The court that is the subject of the contempt usually determines the matter, without a jury.
Facing a contempt allegation or served with a notice to show cause? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation with a criminal defence lawyer before making any statement to the court.
Contempt of court protects the administration of justice. It is a common law offence in Victoria. There is no single Victorian statute that creates a general contempt offence, although particular statutes deal with specific forms of contemptuous conduct. The prosecution must prove contempt beyond reasonable doubt. Where the contempt occurs before the court itself, the judge or magistrate may deal with it immediately and without a jury.
Contempt proceedings are serious. A finding of contempt in the County Court or Supreme Court carries no fixed statutory maximum. The Magistrates' Court has statutory limits for specific contempt offences.
This covers conduct that occurs in or near the courtroom and directly disrupts proceedings. Examples include abusive language directed at a judicial officer, refusing to comply with a lawful direction, disrupting a hearing, or assaulting a person in court. Under s 133 of the Magistrates' Court Act 1989 (Vic), the Magistrates' Court can deal with contempt in the face of the court summarily. The court can act on the spot and impose a penalty without a separate hearing.
Disobedience contempt involves failing to comply with a court order, undertaking, injunction, or suppression order. The non-compliance must be wilful and contumacious: deliberate refusal, not mere inability. Where a person genuinely cannot comply, that goes to whether the contempt can be made out. Disobedience contempt is criminal in character and may result in imprisonment.
Sub judice contempt involves publishing material that creates a real risk of prejudice to pending or current proceedings. Disclosing a defendant's prior criminal history before a verdict, publishing commentary that assumes guilt, or releasing information covered by a suppression order can all constitute sub judice contempt. This category most commonly arises in media and online publishing contexts.
Scandalising contempt involves publishing material that undermines public confidence in the judiciary. This is rarely prosecuted in Australia. Courts have recognised the importance of freedom of expression and criticism of judicial decisions. Strong or even unfair criticism of a judgment is generally not sufficient. The material must impute improper motives or bad faith to the court in a way that threatens its authority.
Conduct that intimidates witnesses, jurors, or legal practitioners, or that retaliates against a person for evidence they gave, constitutes contempt. This includes conduct before, during, or after proceedings. Threatening a witness before they testify, or harassing a juror after a verdict, fall within this category.
| Court / offence type | Maximum penalty |
|---|---|
| Magistrates' Court — contempt in the face of the court (s 133, Magistrates' Court Act 1989 (Vic)) | 6 months' imprisonment and/or 25 penalty units |
| Magistrates' Court — uncooperative witness (ss 133–135, Magistrates' Court Act 1989 (Vic)) | 1 month's imprisonment and/or 5 penalty units |
| County Court and Supreme Court | Discretionary — no fixed statutory ceiling |
One penalty unit equals $209.10 from 1 July 2026. Penalties at the County and Supreme Court level depend on the nature and gravity of the contempt and any mitigating or aggravating factors. Imprisonment is available and has been imposed for serious contempts.
The accused may dispute what was actually said or done, whether the conduct was contemptuous in the circumstances, whether the relevant order existed, or whether the order covered the conduct in question. Where the order is ambiguous, the court will construe it strictly. Non-compliance with an ambiguous order may not constitute contempt if the conduct was consistent with one reasonable reading of it.
For disobedience contempt, the non-compliance must be wilful and contumacious. A genuine inability to comply, such as financial incapacity to pay a fine or physical inability to do an act, may rebut the contempt. Misunderstanding the scope of an order, or acting on legal advice about its meaning, may also be relevant, though advice of counsel is not a complete defence. For sub judice contempt, the prosecution must show the publication created a real risk of prejudice; an absence of knowledge that proceedings were pending may be relevant.
For disobedience contempt, complying with the order after the finding and demonstrating genuine remorse may avoid imprisonment or reduce the penalty. Courts have a discretion to accept a purging of contempt and impose a lesser penalty or suspend the sentence. Purging the contempt does not mean the contempt did not occur. It is a matter that goes to penalty, not to liability.
Facing a contempt allegation in Victoria?
Free consultation. Speak with a criminal defence lawyer before making any statement to the court.