What Complaint Evidence Is
Complaint evidence in the context of a sexual offence trial is evidence that a complainant spoke to a third party about the alleged offence. The complaint witness - the person to whom the disclosure was made - gives evidence about what the complainant told them, when they told them, and how the complainant appeared at the time. The complaint witness may be a friend, family member, partner, colleague, police officer, nurse, counsellor or any other person to whom the complainant made the disclosure.
At common law, evidence of a prior complaint in a sexual offence proceeding was admissible only to shore up the credibility of the complainant as a witness - not as proof of the truth of what was said. The common law also imposed a "recent complaint" requirement that restricted admissibility to complaints made shortly after the alleged offence.
The Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) replaced the common law framework. The High Court of Australia confirmed in The King v Churchill [2025] HCA 11 that the historical common law requirements - including the "causal connection" requirement between the offence and any distress the complainant displayed - have been superseded by the statutory provisions, particularly sections 59, 60, 66 and 164 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) and the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic).
Section 66: The Gateway for Complaint Evidence in Criminal Proceedings
Section 66(2) of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) provides that the hearsay rule does not apply to evidence of a previous representation (the complaint) where:
- (a) the person who made the representation has been or is to be called to give evidence; and
- (b) either: (i) when the representation was made, the occurrence of the asserted fact was fresh in the memory of the person who made the representation; or (ii) the person who made the representation is a victim of an offence to which the proceeding relates and was under the age of 18 years when the representation was made.
Where s.66(2) is satisfied, the complaint evidence is not merely credit evidence - it is admissible as evidence of the truth of the facts stated in the complaint, subject to the court's discretion to exclude it under other provisions of the Act.
The evidence must be given by the person who made the representation (the complainant testifying about what they said) or by a person who saw, heard or otherwise perceived the representation being made (the complaint witness).
Fresh in the Memory: Section 66(2A)
Section 66(2A) of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) provides that in determining whether the occurrence of the asserted fact was fresh in the memory of the person, the court may take into account all matters that it considers are relevant, including the nature of the event concerned and the age and health of the person at the time the representation was made.
Section 66(2A) was introduced in response to the High Court's decision in Graham v The Queen (1998) 195 CLR 606, which had imposed a restrictive interpretation of "fresh in the memory" that required the complaint to have been made shortly after the event. The subsection broadens the enquiry: where the event was traumatic or significant, a complaint made months or even years after the event may still be found to have been fresh in the memory of the complainant, having regard to the nature of the event and all relevant circumstances.
There is no fixed time limit after which a complaint cannot be "fresh in the memory." The court's assessment is contextual and depends on all relevant circumstances, including the nature of the alleged offence, the age and circumstances of the complainant at the time of the disclosure, and the reason for any delay.
Distress Evidence: King v Churchill [2025] HCA 11
In The King v Churchill [2025] HCA 11, the High Court of Australia held that no requirement exists for a "causal connection" to be established between the alleged offence and any distress the complainant displayed when making the complaint before that distress evidence can be used by the jury. The Crown had adduced evidence of the complainant's distress at the time of making the complaint, and the trial judge directed the jury on circumstantial evidence without imposing a causal connection requirement. The Victorian Court of Appeal had found this was an error, holding that the trial judge should have directed the jury that they needed to be satisfied of a rational causal link between the distress and the alleged offending before using that evidence. The High Court reversed that finding, holding that the historical common law requirements - including any causal connection gateway - have been superseded by ss.55, 56, 59, 66, 135, 136 and 137 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) and ss.16, 31, 34, 54K, 61 and 62 of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic). The jury is entitled to consider the distress evidence in accordance with the general principles under the Act, without the additional gateway of a causal connection finding.
The High Court applied and affirmed this position in The King v Tsalkos [2025] HCA 49 (decided September 2025), in which a differently constituted Victorian Court of Appeal had again found miscarriage of justice on the basis of distress evidence directions. The High Court allowed the appeal and restored the respondent's convictions, confirming that Churchill governs the analysis and that evidence of a complainant's distress accompanying a complaint is not to be analysed by reference to whether it constitutes independent corroboration - a concept that has no foundation in the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic).
Delay in Complaint
Delay in making a complaint - or the absence of any complaint for a period - was a significant issue in sexual offence trials under the common law. Evidence that a complainant made no complaint, or made one only after a significant delay, was treated as potentially undermining their credibility.
The Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic) now governs how courts direct juries about delayed complaints in sexual offence proceedings. Section 49 of the Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic) provides that the trial judge must warn the jury that there are good reasons why a person who has been sexually offended against might delay making a complaint or not make one at all, and that absence of complaint or delay in complaining does not necessarily indicate a false allegation. Courts take into account the psychological and social context of delayed disclosure in sexual offence cases, including the dynamics of shame, fear of disbelief, and the relationship between the complainant and accused.
The Complaint Witness at Trial
The complaint witness gives evidence of what the complainant told them and how the complainant appeared at the time. The evidence is ordinarily led by the prosecution. The defence may cross-examine the complaint witness on the circumstances of the disclosure - including the relationship between the complainant and the witness, whether the complainant had discussed the alleged offence with others before making the complaint, any inconsistencies between the complaint and the complainant's evidence at trial, and any demeanour or distress inconsistencies.
Complaint evidence is first-hand hearsay that falls within the s.66 exception. It is not hearsay twice removed - the complaint witness must have themselves seen, heard or perceived the representation being made. A person who was told by a third party about the complainant's complaint does not give admissible complaint evidence under s.66; they would be giving second-hand hearsay that falls outside the first-hand hearsay exception.
The Credibility Rule and Complaint Evidence
Section 102 of the Evidence Act 2008 (Vic) provides that evidence relevant only to a witness's credibility is not admissible (the credibility rule). Under the former common law, complaint evidence was admissible only as credit evidence and was expressly limited to that purpose. Under the Evidence Act 2008, where s.66 applies, complaint evidence is not confined to credibility - it is substantive evidence of the facts asserted. This is a significant change from the common law position and has implications for the weight the jury may give to complaint evidence in a sexual offence trial.
Jury Directions on Complaint Evidence
The Jury Directions Act 2015 (Vic) governs the directions a judge must give about complaint evidence and delayed complaint. Where complaint evidence has been admitted, the judge directs the jury on the basis on which it may be used and reminds them of the matters they may take into account in assessing it. Where there has been delay in complaint, s.49 of the Jury Directions Act 2015 requires the directions identified above about the reasons a person may delay or not make a complaint. Directions are given at the request of a party or on the court's initiative, and their content is tailored to the specific evidence and circumstances of the trial.