The Statutory Framework
The current Victorian legislative framework for venue in higher court criminal trials operates through two provisions of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic).
Section 169 provides that a criminal trial in the Supreme Court or the County Court is to be held in the court sitting at the place that is nearest to the place where the offence is alleged to have been committed, unless an order is made under section 192.
Section 192 allows the court to order that a trial be held at any other place the court considers appropriate if the court considers that a fair trial cannot otherwise be had, or for any other reason it is appropriate to do so.
The two sections work together: s.169 establishes the default position (trial at the nearest court to the alleged offending), and s.192 provides the power to depart from it. The departure is discretionary and requires justification.
The Locality Rule
The default position in s.169 reflects a long-standing principle of Victorian criminal procedure: that trials should ordinarily be held in the locality where the offending is alleged to have occurred. The rationale for this rule was stated by Justice Lush in the unreported decision of R v Ratten (4 August 1970):
"In my opinion, the starting point of a case such as this is that it is a matter of public interest and public policy that a trial should be held in the locality and in the community area in which the crime is alleged to have been committed, so that justice will be seen to be done by those who are interested in seeing it and so that no feeling can arise that justice is done in a distant place and community."
This principle has been reaffirmed in subsequent Victorian decisions and reflects the public interest in criminal justice being administered in the community where the alleged offending occurred - so that justice is seen to be done by those with a stake in seeing it, and so that regional communities are not disenfranchised from proceedings that directly affect them.
The Supreme Court of Victoria has on several occasions emphasised the importance of circuit sittings throughout regional Victoria. The Court is not the Supreme Court of Melbourne but the Supreme Court of Victoria, serving all Victorians.
The Standard for Granting a Change
The test under s.192 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic) is whether a fair trial cannot otherwise be had, or whether for any other reason it is appropriate to order a different venue. The second limb ("any other reason") gives the court broad flexibility, but courts approach the exercise of this discretion with the locality rule firmly in mind.
The Victorian cases establish that a change of venue application requires cogent evidence of a reason that could not be addressed by other means. The proper rule, as stated in the Victorian case law, is that each application falls to be considered on its own merits, and not with any preconceptions, save that a trial should ordinarily proceed in the district in which the offence charged is alleged to have been committed, removal being warranted where sufficient cause is shown.
The following circumstances have been recognised as capable of justifying a change of venue in Victorian criminal proceedings:
- Prejudicial pre-trial publicity: Where pervasive media coverage in the locality where the trial would ordinarily be held has made it impossible or highly unlikely that an impartial jury could be empanelled. The publicity must be sufficiently intense and localised that jury directions and the empanelment process cannot adequately address the prejudice.
- Community size and interconnection: In very small communities where a substantial proportion of the potential jury pool has personal knowledge of the parties, the events, or both, the impossibility of obtaining an impartial jury may be established. However, small community size alone is not sufficient - even in small communities, courts have held that properly directed juries can discharge their obligations.
- Other circumstances making the venue inappropriate: Section 192 also permits a change where for any other reason the court considers it appropriate. Significant logistical or safety circumstances capable of preventing a fair trial, or circumstances that cannot be managed at the original venue by other means, may fall within this limb. However, this discretion is not engaged by inconvenience alone.
What Will Not Succeed
Courts have consistently refused to grant change of venue applications based on the following:
Administrative Convenience Alone
In DPP v Bennett [2004] VSC 148, Justice Cummins addressed an application to move a regional circuit trial to Melbourne on administrative and logistical grounds. His Honour rejected the application in clear terms, observing:
"To remove a circuit trial to Melbourne can lead the vacated community to feel disenfranchised, marginalised or alienated. All this is common experience. This basal requirement should not be watered down by mere administrative convenience. This is the Supreme Court of Victoria, not the Supreme Court of Melbourne."
Administrative inconvenience - including the cost and logistics of running a trial in a regional location - is not a recognised basis for change of venue under Victorian law.
Small Community Size Without More
The mere fact that a trial is to be held in a small regional town is not itself sufficient to establish that a fair trial is impossible. Courts have rejected applications made on the sole basis that the community is small. What is required is evidence that the specific circumstances of this case and this accused in this community make an impartial trial impossible despite the empanelment process.
General Discomfort of the Accused
An accused person's general discomfort with being tried in a particular location, or a subjective perception that local feeling is against them, is not sufficient cause for a change of venue.
Who Can Apply
An application for a change of venue may be made by either the accused or the prosecution. It is made by application to the court in which the trial is to be heard. The application must be supported by evidence - typically affidavit evidence addressing the specific grounds relied upon. Bare assertions without supporting material will not satisfy the court that the threshold for departure from the locality rule has been met.
Applications are typically made before trial but may in some circumstances be made after trial has commenced if the relevant circumstances arise during the proceedings. The timing of any application is a relevant consideration.
The Role of Pre-Trial Publicity
Pre-trial publicity is the most common basis on which change of venue applications are made in Victorian criminal proceedings. However, the mere fact that a case has attracted media attention does not establish that a fair trial is impossible at the original venue. The court will consider:
- The nature, volume and reach of the publicity and how localised it is to the original venue
- The time elapsed between the publicity and the proposed trial - publicity that is remote in time is generally treated as less prejudicial
- Whether the publicity has been factual or whether it contains inflammatory material going beyond the mere reporting of facts
- Whether the publicity extends equally to the proposed alternative venue, in which case a change serves little purpose
- Whether jury directions and standard empanelment procedures are capable of adequately addressing the risk of prejudice
Victorian courts have long recognised that jurors are capable of following directions to put aside material they have heard or read outside the courtroom, and that the oath or affirmation taken by jurors carries real weight. A change of venue will not be granted simply because publicity has occurred - it requires a demonstrated likelihood that the publicity would prevent an impartial jury from being obtained at the original venue despite the empanelment process.
Summary and Magistrates Court Proceedings
The discussion above concerns trials in the Supreme Court and County Court, where s.169 and s.192 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic) apply. For summary proceedings in the Magistrates' Court, section 11 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic) provides that a criminal proceeding in the Magistrates' Court is to be heard at the venue of the court nearest to the place where the offence is alleged to have been committed or, where applicable, the place where the accused was arrested. The Chief Magistrate may nominate a different venue for specified proceedings or classes of proceedings. A proceeding is not invalid merely because it was heard at a venue other than the nearest venue.
Which Courts Are Involved
Change of venue applications in the higher courts are heard by the Supreme Court of Victoria, sitting at 450 Little Bourke Street Melbourne, or by the County Court of Victoria on William Street Melbourne, depending on which court is to conduct the trial. Where a trial is proceeding on circuit - for example at Ballarat, Geelong, Bendigo, Dandenong, or Broadmeadows - the application would be made to that circuit sitting of the relevant court. An order granting a change of venue may move the trial to Melbourne, or to a different regional location.