The Offence: Section 76
Section 76 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) provides that a person is guilty of burglary if they enter any building or part of a building as a trespasser with intent to:
- steal anything in the building;
- commit an offence punishable by imprisonment for 5 years or more involving assault on any person in the building; or
- commit an offence punishable by imprisonment for 5 years or more involving damage to the building or to property in it.
The 5-year threshold for the assault and damage intents is significant: intent to commit a minor common assault (maximum 3 months) would not satisfy the element. Intent to steal carries no equivalent threshold.
The offence is complete upon entry with the requisite intent. No theft, assault or damage needs to have occurred. The maximum penalty is level 5 imprisonment - 10 years.
Section 76 also applies to entry into inhabited vehicles and vessels - a caravan, houseboat or other inhabited vehicle is treated as a building for the purposes of the offence.
Element 1: Entry
The accused must have physically entered the building or a part of it. Entry does not require the accused to have entered fully - a partial entry is sufficient. The question is whether the accused crossed the threshold of the building or the relevant part of it. Entry through a window, door, or other opening all satisfy the element. The accused can enter using an instrument or tool - the element does not require the physical body to be inside the structure.
Element 2: Building or Part of a Building
A building includes any structure that is enclosed to a significant degree. The definition extends to inhabited vehicles and vessels where someone is living in them at the time. Whether a structure or space constitutes a "building" or "part of a building" is a question of fact: R v Cahill [1999] 2 VR 387. Entry into a part of a building - such as a store room, locked office, or restricted floor - can constitute burglary even where the accused was lawfully in another part of the same building. Entry of a part requires that the accused was a trespasser in relation to that part specifically.
Element 3: As a Trespasser
The accused must have entered as a trespasser - without any right or authority to enter: Barker v R (1983) 153 CLR 338. A person enters without right or authority where they have no consent from the occupier or lawful power of entry. A person who enters with permission, but then exceeds the scope of that permission in a way that would make them a trespasser, can be treated as having entered as a trespasser for the relevant part. A person who enters a shop during trading hours is not a trespasser in the general sense, but entry into areas restricted to staff or otherwise outside the scope of the implied permission can constitute trespassory entry.
Element 4: Intent at the Time of Entry
The intent to steal, assault, or cause damage must have existed at the time of entry. A person who enters lawfully and forms the intent to steal only after entry has not committed burglary - though they may be liable for theft if a taking occurs. The intent element is assessed at the moment of entry. Direct evidence of intent is rarely available; the prosecution typically relies on the circumstances of the entry, the time and method of entry, and anything found in the accused's possession.
Aggravated Burglary: Section 77
Section 77 of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) creates aggravated burglary, which carries a maximum of level 2 imprisonment - 25 years. Aggravated burglary is committed where the accused commits burglary and at the time has with them a firearm or imitation firearm, an offensive weapon, or an explosive or imitation explosive, OR where a person is present in the building at the time of the burglary and the accused knew or was reckless as to whether a person was present.
The much higher maximum for aggravated burglary reflects that the legislature treats the presence of a weapon or a person as materially increasing the danger of the conduct.
Which Court Hears This Charge
The court depends on the circumstances of the charge. Burglary with intent to steal property valued under $100,000 may be heard in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria. Burglary with intent to steal property over $100,000, or with intent to assault or cause damage, must be committed to the County Court of Victoria on William Street Melbourne. Aggravated burglary under s.77 is a strictly indictable offence heard only in the County Court. In regional Victoria, matters may be heard at Broadmeadows Magistrates' Court, Dandenong Magistrates' Court, Ringwood Magistrates' Court or Frankston Magistrates' Court depending on where the offending occurred.
Defences
The most commonly contested elements are the trespass element and the intent element. Where the accused had genuine consent to enter, or held an honest belief that they had consent, the trespass element may not be established. Where the intent to steal or cause harm was not formed until after entry, the intent element fails. Self-defence under s.322K of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic) is available in limited circumstances. Duress and claim of right may also be relevant depending on the facts.