The Offence: Section 53
Section 53 of the Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic) requires that records kept under a taxation law must be kept in a form and manner that makes them accessible - meaning they must be capable of being produced for inspection by the Commissioner of State Revenue (the Commissioner) when required. A person who fails to keep required records in an accessible form commits an offence under s.53. The maximum penalty is 200 penalty units ($41,820.00 at the 2026-27 rate) in the case of a body corporate, and 40 penalty units ($8,364.00) in any other case.
The Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic) is a State law administered by the State Revenue Office Victoria (SRO). It governs the administration and enforcement of Victoria's state taxation laws, including land tax, duties, payroll tax, the fire services levy, and other taxes administered by the SRO. It is distinct from the Commonwealth Taxation Administration Act 1953, which governs the Australian Taxation Office and federal taxes including income tax and GST.
What the Prosecution Must Prove
To secure a conviction under s.53, the prosecution must establish beyond reasonable doubt that:
- the accused was required to keep a record under a taxation law;
- the accused kept that record in a form or manner that was not accessible; and
- the accused did not have a lawful excuse for the failure to maintain accessibility.
What Records Must Be Kept
The obligation to keep records under s.53 derives from the underlying taxation law that applies to the taxpayer's circumstances. Different taxation laws impose different record-keeping obligations. For example, the Duties Act 2000 (Vic) requires persons involved in dutiable transactions to keep records of those transactions. The Land Tax Act 2005 (Vic) imposes record-keeping obligations on landowners in relation to their ownership and the use of their land. The Payroll Tax Act 2007 (Vic) requires employers to keep records of wages paid. In each case, the nature of the records required is defined by the specific taxation law, and s.53 requires those records to be maintained in an accessible form.
What "Accessible" Means
For the purposes of s.53, accessibility means that the records are kept in a form and manner that allows them to be produced for inspection without unreasonable difficulty. Records stored electronically must be capable of being retrieved and presented in a readable format. Records in a language other than English must be capable of being translated. Records stored in a format that requires specialist equipment to access, or stored in conditions that make retrieval impractical, may not satisfy the accessibility requirement. The test is whether the Commissioner, on requesting access to the records, can practically inspect and review them.
Accessibility vs Possession
Section 53 is not an offence of failing to keep records - that is covered by section 50 of the Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic). The s.53 offence is specifically directed at the form in which records that exist are kept. A person who has kept all required records but stored them in a manner that prevents the Commissioner from inspecting them on request commits the s.53 offence. The distinction is between the existence of records (s.50) and their accessibility (s.53).
Defences
The Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic) provides a defence in s.69 for a person who took reasonable precautions and exercised due diligence to avoid the non-compliance. If records became inaccessible as a result of circumstances beyond the accused's control - such as a fire, flood, or equipment failure - and the accused took reasonable steps to prevent the loss of accessibility and to obtain substitute records, the defence under s.69 may be available. The accused bears the evidential burden of pointing to evidence capable of supporting the defence; the prosecution then bears the persuasive burden of disproving it.
Which Court Hears This Charge
All charges under s.53 of the Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic) are heard in the Magistrates' Court of Victoria. In Melbourne, matters are listed at Melbourne Magistrates' Court on William Street. This is a regulatory offence heard summarily without a jury. The penalty is a fine rather than imprisonment; no term of imprisonment is available for the s.53 offence.
Relationship to Other Taxation Record-Keeping Offences
Section 53 sits within a group of related record-keeping offences in the Taxation Administration Act 1997 (Vic). Section 50 creates the offence of failing to keep required records. Section 51 creates the offence of failing to keep additional records when required to do so by written notice from the Commissioner. Section 52 creates the offence of making or including false or misleading information in required records. Section 55 deals with the period of retention of records. Each offence addresses a different aspect of the record-keeping obligations under the Act.