Honest and Reasonable Mistake of Belief | Victorian Criminal Defence
Victorian criminal defences · Strict liability

Honest and Reasonable Mistake of Fact

Honest and reasonable mistake of fact is a defence to strict liability offences in Victoria. It applies where the accused held a genuine belief in facts that, if true, would have made their conduct lawful, and where that belief was objectively reasonable.

Charged with a strict liability offence? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation with a criminal defence lawyer to assess whether this defence is available on the facts.

Overview

Most criminal offences require the prosecution to prove a fault element (intention, knowledge, recklessness, or negligence) before a conviction can follow. Strict liability offences are different. They remove the need for the prosecution to prove any fault element at all. A person can be convicted simply because they did the act, regardless of what they believed or intended.

The honest and reasonable mistake of fact defence restores a degree of fairness. It allows a person charged with a strict liability offence to avoid conviction by showing they held an honest belief in a state of facts which, if true, would have made the conduct innocent. The principle was stated by Dixon J in Proudman v Dayman (1941) 67 CLR 536 and confirmed by the High Court in He Kaw Teh v The Queen (1985) 157 CLR 523.

Types of Criminal Liability

Understanding which type of liability applies to a charge determines whether this defence is available.

Ordinary (fault-based) offences

The prosecution must prove a fault element: intention, knowledge, recklessness, or negligence. A mistaken belief about the facts may negate the fault element itself, without needing a separate defence. Honest and reasonable mistake does not operate as a standalone defence to these charges.

Strict liability offences

No fault element must be proved. The prosecution proves the accused did the act. The honest and reasonable mistake of fact defence is available and, if raised, operates as a complete defence. A common example in Victoria is driving while suspended under the Road Safety Act 1986 (Vic). A driver who genuinely and reasonably believed their licence was valid may have a defence, even though the offence itself requires no proof of knowledge.

Absolute liability offences

No fault element is required, and the defence of honest and reasonable mistake is not available. These are rare. They are reserved for regulatory contexts where Parliament has made clear that no mistake, however reasonable, can excuse the conduct.

The Three Elements

To rely on this defence, the accused must establish three things:

  • Honest belief: The belief must be genuinely held at the time of the conduct, not reconstructed after the fact.
  • Reasonable belief: The belief must be one that a reasonable person in the same circumstances would have held. A belief may be honest but still fail this limb if no reasonable person would have held it.
  • Mistake of fact, not law: The belief must concern facts, not the legal consequences of those facts. Ignorance of the law, meaning not knowing that the conduct was an offence, is not a defence.

Onus of Proof

The accused carries an evidential burden. They must put forward enough material, from their own evidence or from cross-examination of prosecution witnesses, to raise the defence as a live issue. Once they do, the prosecution must disprove the defence beyond reasonable doubt. The accused does not have to prove their belief was honest and reasonable; the prosecution must prove it was not.

Dixon J in Proudman v Dayman (1941) 67 CLR 536 held that it is a good defence to a strict liability offence that the defendant believed on reasonable grounds in a state of facts which, if they existed, would have made the conduct innocent. The High Court confirmed this principle in He Kaw Teh v The Queen (1985) 157 CLR 523.

Mistakes of Law Are Not Covered

The defence is limited to mistakes of fact. A person who knew the facts but was wrong about the legal consequences of those facts cannot rely on it. If a driver knew their licence had been suspended but believed the suspension was unlawful, that is a mistake of law. The suspension still applies, and the defence does not assist.

Similarly, if a person failed to update their address with the licensing authority and therefore did not receive a suspension notice, whether the defence succeeds depends on whether the failure to update was itself reasonable. A court will ask what a reasonable person in the same position would have known and done.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this defence apply to all criminal charges in Victoria? +
No. The defence applies only to strict liability offences. For offences that require proof of a fault element (intention, knowledge, recklessness, or negligence), a mistaken belief may negate the fault element directly. For absolute liability offences, no mistake, however genuine and reasonable, can provide a defence.
Who has to prove the defence? +
The accused carries an evidential burden: they must raise enough material to put the defence in issue. Once they do, the prosecution must disprove the honest and reasonable belief beyond reasonable doubt. The accused does not carry a legal burden of proof on this issue.
Can I use this defence if I did not receive the suspension notice? +
It depends on the reason. If the notice was not received because of an error by the licensing authority or a third party, and the accused genuinely and reasonably believed their licence was valid, the defence may succeed. If the accused failed to update their address with the licensing authority, a court will consider whether that failure was itself reasonable. The outcome is fact-specific and often turns on detailed evidence.
Is this the same as the defence of mistake of fact under the Criminal Code? +
The Criminal Code Act 1995 (Cth) codifies a mistake of fact defence for federal strict liability offences at s 9.2. The Victorian common law defence, established in Proudman v Dayman (1941) 67 CLR 536, operates in a similar way for state offences. The elements and onus provisions are broadly consistent, but the applicable law depends on whether the charge is a state or federal offence.
What evidence supports this defence? +
Evidence that can support the defence includes: correspondence or records showing the accused had no notice of the relevant fact; evidence that the licensing authority or relevant body made an error; evidence of steps the accused took to confirm the position; and character evidence going to the reasonableness of the belief. The strength of the evidence will determine whether the prosecution can disprove it beyond reasonable doubt.

Charged with a strict liability offence in Victoria?

A free consultation gives you an honest assessment of the evidence and whether this defence applies.
Call 1300 331 331
Scroll to Top
Call Now Contact
Us