Consent as a Defence in Victorian Sexual Offences — Australian Criminal Lawyers
Victorian criminal law · Criminal defences

Consent as a Defence in Victorian Sexual Offences

Under Victoria's affirmative consent model (in force from 30 July 2023), consent means free and voluntary agreement — and the prosecution must prove both that consent was absent and that the accused lacked a reasonable belief in consent. Silence, passivity, and absence of objection no longer support any inference that consent was given.

Facing a sexual offence charge? Call 1300 331 331 for a free consultation — the consent laws changed substantially in 2023 and specialist advice is essential.

Overview

Consent is a central element of most sexual offences under Victorian law. The prosecution must prove beyond reasonable doubt both that the relevant sexual act occurred without the complainant's consent and that the accused did not have a reasonable belief in consent. These are two distinct elements — each must be established independently. The law governing consent in Victoria is found in the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic), primarily in ss 36, 36AA, and 36A, significantly amended by the Justice Legislation Amendment (Sexual Offences and Other Matters) Act 2022, which came into effect on 30 July 2023, introducing an affirmative consent model.

What Consent Means Under Victorian Law

Section 36 defines consent as free and voluntary agreement. It cannot be assumed, implied from silence, or inferred from a lack of resistance. Two core principles follow: (1) a person does not consent simply because they do not resist verbally or physically; and (2) prior consent to a sexual act — whether the same type or a different one, with that person or anyone else — does not establish consent to a current act. Consent must be present at the time of the act and is ongoing throughout any sexual activity. A person can withdraw consent at any point.

Offences for Which Consent Is an Element

  • Rape (s 38) — intentional sexual penetration without consent and without a reasonable belief in consent. Maximum: 25 years imprisonment.
  • Sexual assault (s 40) — intentional sexual touching without consent and without a reasonable belief in consent. Maximum: 10 years imprisonment.
  • Compelling sexual penetration (s 39), assault with intent to commit a sexual offence (s 42), compelling sexual touching (s 41) — each requires absence of consent as an element.

When a Person Is Deemed Not to Have Consented

Section 36AA sets out a non-exhaustive list of circumstances in which a person is taken not to have consented, including where the person:
  • Was asleep or unconscious
  • Was so affected by alcohol or drugs as to be incapable of consenting or withdrawing consent
  • Was incapable of understanding the sexual nature of the act
  • Was mistaken about the sexual nature of the act or the identity of the other person
  • Participated due to force, fear of force, or harm or fear of harm of any type — including economic, reputational, family violence, or employment-related harm — directed at themselves, another person, or an animal
  • Participated due to unlawful detention or abuse of a position of trust, authority, or dependence
  • Was deceived as to the nature or purpose of the act, including false representations connected to payment for sexual services
  • Submitted because consent was contingent on a condom being used, but the other person intentionally removed, tampered with, or did not use one — the conduct referred to as "stealthing," confirmed by DPP v Yeong [2022] VSCA 179

Reasonable Belief in Consent: The Affirmative Standard

Section 36A governs what counts as a reasonable belief in consent. Under the current law, a belief in consent is not reasonable if the accused did not say or do anything to find out whether the other person was consenting — within a reasonable time before or at the time the sexual act took place. This is the affirmative consent requirement. It places the focus on what steps the accused took to confirm consent, rather than simply on what the complainant did or did not do. There is a limited exception under s 36A(3) where the accused had a cognitive impairment or mental illness that was a substantial cause of their not taking steps to ascertain consent — but s 36A(4) places the burden of proving that exception on the accused, on the balance of probabilities. Section 36B addresses intoxication: if the accused's intoxication was self-induced, the standard is that of a sober reasonable person in the same circumstances. If not self-induced, the standard is that of a reasonable person intoxicated to the same extent.

The Significance of the 2022 Reforms

Before these changes, the assessment centred primarily on the complainant's conduct — what they said or did not say, and what the accused perceived. The current framework reorients that inquiry. It requires those engaging in sexual activity to actively seek and confirm consent. Silence, passivity, and an absence of objection no longer support any inference that consent was given.

Facing a sexual offence charge in Victoria?

Speak with a criminal defence lawyer — free, no obligation consultation.
Call 1300 331 331
Scroll to Top
Call Now Contact
Us